Willow Peterson, a young widow, settles in the town of Cripple Creek with the dream of becoming an artist. Fortunately, she soon gets a job as a portrait painter with Trenton Van Der Veer, a handsome entrepreneur and photographer. However, Willow's blossoming romance and the family bonds of the Sinclair sisters are shaken by some new arrivals in town. Can everyone hold it together?

Vivian, the youngest Sinclair sister, moves from Maine to Cripple Creek, Colorado, and joins Kat, Nell and Ida. However, she sees herself as tainted by her past decisions and doesn't think she could ever be happily married like her sisters. Will an outpouring of God's grace remind her how worthy she truly is?

Ida Sinclair moves to Cripple Creek for one reason --- to work with successful businesswoman Mollie O'Bryan. However, Ida's sisters and the town as a whole think Ida should spend a little less time working and a little more time looking for a beau. Will Ida discover where her priorities really lie?

Kat and Nell Sinclair head west to Colorado as mail-order brides. When they get to the town of Cripple Creek, though, their fiancés are nowhere to be found. Can these two prim and proper women make it on their own in the wild west?