A newly divorced Brynn thought she had found her happy ending. But now she’s living with a roommate, Josh, to afford her mortgage, and she’s trying to adjust to her new single life. At least she has “Carson’s Cove,” her beloved 2000s teenage soap, to binge. The show ended on a cliffhanger after five seasons, and the two main characters, Sloan and Spencer, never got to declare their love for each other. When a birthday cake surprisingly shows up on her and Josh’s doorstep, Brynn makes a wish for the one thing she’s always wanted: a happily ever after. The next morning, she doesn’t wake up in her apartment. She’s in Carson’s Cove, and Josh is there too. Everyone seems to know them, except they’re not Brynn and Josh. They’re Sloan, the sweetheart of Carson’s Cove, and Fletch, the town’s bad boy.

When Gemma gets dumped by her long-term boyfriend, she gets drunk with her sister, kooky aunt and best friend, Dax. After one too many margaritas, they decide to perform a love-cleansing spell, which promises to erase Gemma’s ex from her memory. They follow all the instructions, including a platonic kiss from Dax to seal the deal. When Gemma wakes up, she realizes that this silly spell has worked. Not only does it seem that she never dated her ex, the rest of her life is completely unrecognizable. The worst part: Dax has no idea who she is. To reverse the spell and get back to her old life, Gemma must convince her once-best-friend-now-near-stranger to kiss her. But as she carries out her plans, she finds herself falling for him --- hard. Soon, Gemma begins to wonder if she even wants to go back to the way things once were.