The Secret Christmas Library
Review
The Secret Christmas Library
Whether it's the seaside or a charming corner of Edinburgh, Jenny Colgan’s settings never fail to enchant and charm us. THE SECRET CHRISTMAS LIBRARY is no different. The book takes place in a castle in northern Scotland during the freezing winter. It is breathtaking as Colgan describes the heaps of brilliant white snow, the sparkling sea, the majestic stag, and the centerpiece: a massive, decaying, neglected, isolated estate.
Mirren Sutherland loves books. She was featured in a short story by Colgan, "The Christmas Book Hunt," and her discovery of a valuable book is referenced. This time, she is reunited with Theo Palliser, an antiquarian bookseller with whom she had a romantic relationship in "The Christmas Book Hunt." He ghosted her, and she’s not sure she’s still interested.
"There's action, danger, humor and, of course, romance. I found that when I wasn't reading, I was thinking about the story and the people and wondering what would happen next."
Jamie McKinnon, a Scottish laird, lives in a crumbling castle on the northern coast of Scotland, and he desperately needs money to keep the estate from ruin. His grandfather left hints that there is a valuable book somewhere, and he hires Mirren and Theo to find it. But his grandfather was a book hoarder, and there are literally thousands of books crammed and stacked not only in every room of the huge building, but in all the outbuildings and barns.
In true Colgan style, we meet characters who are mostly likable. All are flawed, but each has redeeming qualities. Mirren is insecure, especially when confronted with "posh" people like Jamie; his sister, Esme; and Theo. Jamie is the laird, but he really wants to be a gardener. Esme hangs on to the wealthy friends she made at her private school, living in their vacation homes and on their yachts, but it's not the lifestyle she'd choose. She desperately wants the money to enable her to live as she desires. Theo grew up as the poor relation in an upper-class family. And there is also the housekeeper at the castle, Bonnie. Mirren can't understand why Bonnie would stay in the remote location instead of leaving for university or living in a city where she could meet other young people.
It's winter, and Colgan brilliantly communicates what it means when the air temperature is below freezing and there's no central heat. The windows in the building are ancient and single-paned, and the wood is crumbling and damp. The corridors are cavernous, and the wind doesn't stop blowing.
In fact, when a storm brings a massive amount of snow, the electricity goes off. The four must search for the valuable book by sunlight during the day and by candlelight after the sun goes down, which in that northern region happens early in the afternoon. Jamie's grandfather left clues, and they must solve each one before finding the next clue. They aren't even sure that there is a treasure at the end of the line, but Jamie is desperate, so they keep looking.
Colgan's stories are all about family and what ties us together. In this touching novel, as they uncover additional clues about the book, Mirren and Jamie also learn more about Jamie’s grandfather and his tragic life. Things are not always as they appear, and Jamie must decide if he will make the same mistakes his grandfather made.
There's action, danger, humor and, of course, romance. I found that when I wasn't reading, I was thinking about the story and the people and wondering what would happen next. That's the sure sign of an engaging novel and characters we admire. I shivered along with them as they braved deep snow drifts, and I wished I had an AGA stove to warm me up.
Escape your easy life with central heat and windows that keep the cold out. Travel to Scotland and feel the frigid air, along with the desperation of trying to figure out cryptic clues to find a treasure before a crumbling castle falls down about your head. Enjoy the sweet romance, and be amused at the doings of Jamie's posh sister. This lovely holiday story will warm your heart and put a smile on your face, no matter the season.
Reviewed by Pamela Kramer on December 5, 2025
The Secret Christmas Library
- Publication Date: October 14, 2025
- Genres: Fiction, Mystery, Romance, Women's Fiction
- Paperback: 320 pages
- Publisher: William Morrow Paperbacks
- ISBN-10: 0063437376
- ISBN-13: 9780063437371


