Peculiar Stars
Review
Peculiar Stars
Rebecca Yarros became a household name with the hugely successful FOURTH WING and the subsequent books in the series. In fact, on a flight from Mexico, the woman next to me in the center seat was reading FOURTH WING. The young lady next to her in the window seat joined the conversation and said she was reading the sequel. It's no wonder that it hit #1 on the New York Times bestseller list.
Yarros’ new novel, PECULIAR STARS, isn't a fantasy, and there are no dragons. In fact, it's a story of love, survival and betrayal. Callista Moran meets Darren Knight in college. While he is the scion of an extremely wealthy family, she is attending college on a scholarship and working to make ends meet. Although they come from different worlds, they date for years and eventually get engaged.
"Although the book is 640 pages, I flew through it. I loved reading about their survival efforts and vicariously living the life of the rich and famous. It was a pleasure, and those who loved FOURTH WING will enjoy this thrilling, albeit much different, novel."
Darren's mother is determined to control every aspect of Callista's life --- from her appearance to her deportment, from the color of her hair to the height of her heels. Callista listens and obeys because she loves Darren and feels lucky to be in his life. Her mother is thrilled that she will be part of a large family and will never have to worry about money.
When we meet Callista --- who, through a misunderstanding, was given the nickname Lilly by Darren --- she is being rushed to the hospital and is in great pain. Her leg is injured, and the narrative creates a sense of urgency as we see the doctors and nurses anxiously working to stabilize her. It turns out that her leg was broken a week before.
The rhythm of the book is unusual. Some chapters, those titled “Present Day,” are what is happening right now, after Callista's rescue from the island where she lived for 18 months with the crew from the ship she was on and her fiancé's relative. Other chapters are called “Sailing Day” and “Day 7,” with the number of days that have elapsed since Callista left on her doomed sailing trip, which she definitely did not want to take because she was deathly afraid of boats and the ocean. Darren, whose family loved sailing, basically forced her to do it to get to their engagement party. And that's when everything went bad. There was a cyclone that unexpectedly changed course, and the ship was in the middle of it.
Not only do the chapters alternate in time, they are all told in the first person with chapters labeled “Callista” or “Dominic,” depending on the narrator. We see Callista struggle to return to normal life following over 500 days of survival and heartbreak. Both time periods are moving forward, and what we learn in the present only causes us to have more questions about the past. What happened during the cyclone and on the island? And, perhaps most importantly, how were they saved?
The other main character is Dominic, whose relationship to Darren isn't clear at the start. We do know that he’s basically Darren on steroids: bigger, taller, more confident and smarter. He's everything that Darren would like to be, but he doesn't flaunt it. He isn't sure he trusts Callista at first because, after all, she's Darren's fiancée. But this is a love story, so mistrust turns to lust. And there's a lot to get through before that situation is resolved.
PECULIAR STARS addresses how struggles form us and how going through hell changes a person and his or her priorities and self-image. Will Callista settle for a life as Darren's wife, or will she demand more? While she sometimes drives us nuts (we want to shake her and tell her to stand up for herself), she's basically a really good person. She tries to ameliorate every difficulty, bring people together, and make those around her happy.
Although the book is 640 pages, I flew through it. I loved reading about their survival efforts and vicariously living the life of the rich and famous. It was a pleasure, and those who loved FOURTH WING will enjoy this thrilling, albeit much different, novel.
Reviewed by Pamela Kramer on November 20, 2026


