Murder on 34th Street
Review
Murder on 34th Street
Mariah Fredericks, the critically acclaimed author of THE LINDBERGH NANNY and THE WHARTON PLOT, returns with MURDER ON 34th STREET, a dazzling novel set just before and during one of the country's most famous traditions.
It is not every day you get a letter from Santa Claus, yet that is exactly what has just happened to Grace Verlander when we meet her at her desk in the personnel department of Macy’s flagship store at Herald Square in New York City. The year is 1932, the ninth iteration of the famed Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade is only one day away, and this year the stakes are higher than ever following the crash that depleted the bank accounts and hopes of the nation.
A letter from Santa normally would be welcome, perhaps a promise of an extravagant gift to come or even a cheeky IOU. Instead, the note reads: I fear I am in danger. It isn’t from the North Pole’s most famous dweller himself, but from Harry Gardner, the jolliest soul working in children’s shoes and the store’s secret Santa. His identity is protected to both uphold the magic and prevent mayhem. But the Harry Gardner who Grace finds on Macy’s eighth floor is neither jolly nor magical. He is scared, and for good reason: he has received his own note, only his is far more ominous. SANTA WON’T LIVE TO SEE CHRISTMAS, it proclaims.
"Fredericks truly has outdone herself here. I cannot think of an amateur sleuth I have enjoyed more in recent memory than Grace Verlander.... A standout hit from an author who gets better with each book, MURDER ON 34th STREET is perfect for fans of Fiona Davis, Jess Kidd and Benjamin Stevenson."
If there’s one thing that Grace is especially good at, it’s knowing people --- how they work, what makes them tick, who’s hiding what. With her trademark no-nonsense efficiency and approach, she quickly dispatches the head of security, Detective Frank Halsey, to stand watch on the Santa’s workshop float that Harry will be manning. She also meets with the store’s window and float designer, Raymond Di Nunzio, a man seemingly chiseled from marble, kissed by the gods, and blessed with devilish cheekbones to boot. Grace and Raymond have been dutifully employed in a flirtatious game of cat-and-mouse for months, but when it comes to his work, she knows that there’s no one more serious or less interested in leaving anything to chance. Thinking the problem solved, or at the very least avoided, Grace resumes her normal daily routine.
True to form, the parade is a resounding success but with one hiccup. When a balloon bursts, creating a gunshot-like popping sound, it is immediately followed by a second pop and concludes with the death of Macy’s head of security. Santa has made it through the parade, but not Detective Halsey.
Putting her personnel training to good use, Grace is quickly able to pin down a suspect: Bert Pitt, a drunk she was forced to fire and who promised it wouldn’t be the last she saw of him. But when her best friend, Lillian, and truck driver Stu McBride disappear during and after the parade, Grace starts to wonder if an entire murder plot can really be pinned on a disgruntled alcoholic. Macy’s and the New York Police Department agree to call Halsey’s death “a heart attack” until after the holidays, so Grace must tread carefully in her investigation.
But that’s not all she’s up against. Even though she is the veritable beating heart of all of Macy’s operations, she is also, much to everyone’s disappointment, a woman --- that most foolish and untrustworthy of things, according to her bosses and the police. But Grace is no ordinary woman --- she’s sharp, unflinching, and in possession of a wild, bawdy sense of humor. This intoxicating blend allows her to rapidly size up and form judgments about anyone she meets, especially her employees.
As the threats continue to pile up, with the second victim being Harry’s own Santa suit, shredded into ribbons, Grace continues to poke around, identifying suspects and allies in every department. But when one of her own, the young idealist Johnny Petrocelli, is blamed for both Harry’s threatening message and Halsey’s murder, Grace must kick her investigation into high gear. Johnny may be a deviant, a rebel and a fool, but all that tells her is that he is not a killer. She’ll do anything to figure out who is, especially if it means protecting her beloved store, the people she represents there, and her own peace of mind.
What follows is both an immersive, glittering portrayal of 1930s New York City and a riveting mystery with numerous suspects, red herrings and plot twists. Bolstering these are, of course, Grace herself, an inimitable character with one of the best senses of humor I have ever encountered --- on the page or off.
As a work of historical fiction, MURDER ON 34th STREET is everything readers have come to love from Mariah Fredericks: a keen eye for historical detail, meticulous research, believable characters, and a setting that practically erects itself around you. As a holiday whodunit, full of the glimmering magic of the season, the gift of suspense, and a cast of characters as personable and memorable as those from any Christmas special, it absolutely soars.
Fredericks truly has outdone herself here. I cannot think of an amateur sleuth I have enjoyed more in recent memory than Grace Verlander. And while a romance storyline can often undermine or weigh down a strong mystery plot like this, even Grace's banter with Raymond finds a structurally sound, satisfying home amid the peppering of twists, clues and misdirects.
A standout hit from an author who gets better with each book, MURDER ON 34th STREET is perfect for fans of Fiona Davis, Jess Kidd and Benjamin Stevenson.
Reviewed by Rebecca Munro on November 6, 2026
Murder on 34th Street
- Publication Date: October 6, 2026
- Genres: Fiction, Historical Fiction, Historical Mystery, Mystery
- Hardcover: 288 pages
- Publisher: Minotaur Books
- ISBN-10: 1250367549
- ISBN-13: 9781250367549


