Bookreporter Reviewers' Favorite Books of 2025
Reviewer Picks
Bookreporter Reviewers' Favorite Books of 2025
Recently we asked our reviewers to provide us with a list of their favorite books from 2025. Included is a mix of fiction and nonfiction titles, all published for the first time this year. We always love hearing which books resonated the most with them! Please note that due to personal and professional commitments, some reviewers were not able to participate in this feature.
Kate Ayers
- THE TIN MEN by Nelson DeMille and Alex DeMille
- TWICE by Mitch Albom
- HEAD CASES by John McMahon
- TYPEWRITER BEACH by Meg Waite Clayton
- THE GUEST IN ROOM 120 by Sara Ackerman
- THE RED HOUSE by Mary Morris
- TELL ME WHAT YOU DID by Carter Wilson
- LLOYD McNEIL’S LAST RIDE by Will Leitch
- THE DOORMAN by Chris Pavone
-
THE IMPOSSIBLE FORTUNE: A Thursday Murder Club Mystery by Richard Osman
Curtis Edmonds
- 1929: Inside the Greatest Crash in Wall Street History — and How it Shattered a Nation, by Andrew Ross Sorkin
- THE MARTIANS: The True Story of an Alien Craze that Captured Turn-of-the-Century America, by David Baron
- THE GALES OF NOVEMBER: The Untold Story of the Edmund Fitzgerald, by John U. Bacon
- ANGEL DOWN by Daniel Kraus
- MIDNIGHT ON THE POTOMAC: The Last Year of the Civil War, the Lincoln Assassination, and the Rebirth of America, by Scott Ellsworth
- EVERYBODY WANTS TO RULE THE WORLD EXCEPT ME by Django Wexler
-
LETHAL PREY: A Lucas Davenport and Virgil Flowers Novel by John Sandford
Sarah Rachel Egelman
- A MARRIAGE AT SEA: A True Story of Love, Obsession, and Shipwreck by Sophie Elmhirst
-
IDLE GROUNDS by Krystelle Bamford
Megan Elliott
- THE PRETENDER by Jo Harkin
- DEEP CUTS by Holly Brickley
- MOOD MACHINE: The Rise of Spotify and the Costs of the Perfect Playlist, by Liz Pelly
- EL DORADO DRIVE by Megan Abbott
- LITTLE BOSSES EVERYWHERE: How the Pyramid Scheme Shaped America, by Bridget Read
- THE HARDER I FIGHT, THE MORE I LOVE YOU: A Memoir by Neko Case
- MURDERLAND: Crime and Bloodlust in the Time of Serial Killers, by Caroline Fraser
- PERSPECTIVE(S) written by Laurent Binet, translated by Sam Taylor
- AMONG FRIENDS by Hal Ebbott
-
COVER STORY by Mhairi McFarlane
Harvey Freedenberg
- THE ANTIDOTE by Karen Russell
- THE GOSSIP COLUMNIST’S DAUGHTER by Peter Orner
- WHAT WE CAN KNOW by Ian McEwan
- JOYRIDE: A Memoir by Susan Orlean
- ONE OF US by Dan Chaon
- MOTHERS AND SONS by Adam Haslett
- THE IMAGINED LIFE by Andrew Porter
- THE EMPEROR OF GLADNESS by Ocean Vuong
- SO FAR GONE by Jess Walter
- WE THE PEOPLE: A History of the U.S. Constitution by Jill Lepore
- HEART, BE AT PEACE by Donal Ryan
-
MEMORIAL DAYS: A Memoir by Geraldine Brooks
Ron Kaplan
- MAKE ME COMMISSIONER: I Know What's Wrong with Baseball and How to Fix It by Jane Leavy
- I FELT THE CHEERS: The Remarkable Silent Life of Curtis Pride, by Curtis Pride with Doug Ward
- SKIPPER: Why Baseball Managers Matter and Always Will by Scott Miller
- THE ANCIENT WISDOM OF BASEBALL: Lessons for Life from Homer's Odyssey to the World Series, by Christian Sheppard
- IN THE JAPANESE BALLPARK: Behind the Scenes of Nippon Professional Baseball, by Robert K. Fitts
-
ONE SPLENDID SEASON: Baseball and America in 1912, Told with the Words and Images of the Hassan Triplefolder Set, by Phil Rosenzweig
Pamela Kramer
- WE ARE ALL GUILTY HERE by Karin Slaughter --- a great first book in a new series
- THE BLACK WOLF by Louise Penny --- just brilliant
- MICHAEL WITHOUT APOLOGY by Catherine Ryan Hyde --- an unforgettable novel with many important messages
- WAYWARD GIRLS by Susan Wiggs --- historical fiction that needs to be read
- THE CONFESSIONS by Paul Bradley Carr --- AI and a mystery with great twists
- THE CORRESPONDENT by Virginia Evans --- a thoughtful epistolary novel
- THE LOVE HATERS by Katherine Center --- her romances are delightful
- THE BLANKET CATS written by Kiyoshi Shigematsu, translated by Jesse Kirkwood --- a beautiful collection of short stories about the magical power of cats
- MY FRIENDS by Fredrik Backman --- powerful and strangely creative as only Backman can write
- JENNY COOPER HAS A SECRET by Joy Fielding --- a deliciously devilish novel with a fabulous twist
- 10 MARCHFIELD SQUARE by Nicola Whyte --- a brilliant mystery with a perfect setting
- FEVER BEACH by Carl Hiaasen --- irreverent and humor-filled with crazy characters
- THE WOMEN ON PLATFORM TWO by Laura Anthony --- great historical fiction
- EDDIE WINSTON IS LOOKING FOR LOVE by Marianne Cronin --- charming and touching
-
THE LOTUS SHOES by Jane Yang --- shocking historical fiction about women in China
Bronwyn Miller
- THE CORRESPONDENT by Virginia Evans
- THE CARPOOL DETECTIVES: A True Story of Four Moms, Two Bodies, and One Mysterious Cold Case by Chuck Hogan
- EVERYONE IS LYING TO YOU by Jo Piazza
- WILD DARK SHORE by Charlotte McConaghy
- ATMOSPHERE: A Love Story by Taylor Jenkins Reid
- ACTRESS OF A CERTAIN AGE: My Twenty-Year Trail to Overnight Success, by Jeff Hiller
- CARELESS PEOPLE: A Cautionary Tale of Power, Greed, and Lost Idealism, by Sarah Wynn-Williams
-
THREE DAYS IN JUNE by Anne Tyler
Rebecca Munro
- MORE OR LESS MADDY by Lisa Genova
- THE THREE LIVES OF CATE KAY by Kate Fagan
- WHAT HAPPENED TO THE McCRAYS? by Tracey Lange
- BROKEN COUNTRY by Clare Leslie Hall
- COUNT MY LIES by Sophie Stava
- WILD DARK SHORE by Charlotte McConaghy
- THE FAVORITES by Layne Fargo
- THE JACKAL'S MISTRESS by Chris Bohjalian
- THE BRIGHT YEARS by Sarah Damoff
- BOOM TOWN by Nic Stone
- BURY OUR BONES IN THE MIDNIGHT SOIL by V. E. Schwab
- WHAT KIND OF PARADISE by Janelle Brown
- WITCHCRAFT FOR WAYWARD GIRLS by Grady Hendrix
- THE DEAD HUSBAND COOKBOOK by Danielle Valentine
- THIS HAPPENED TO ME: A Reckoning by Kate Price
- THE MAD WIFE by Meagan Church
- RED CITY by Marie Lu
-
THE EVERLASTING by Alix E. Harrow
L. Dean Murphy
Dean's List
-
MIDNIGHT BURNING: An Einstein-Chaplin Thriller by Paul Levine
Aside from Einstein, the genius in this book is Paul Levine, who uses real people and true events to weave an intricate thriller tapestry in a tale that has more plot turns than a spiral staircase. -
THE GIRL IN THE GREEN DRESS: A Mystery Featuring Zelda Fitzgerald by Mariah Fredericks
THE GIRL IN THE GREEN DRESS is over-the-top brilliant, an iconic fact-based work of art. Since this is a mystery, an Anthony Award nomination is assured. -
LINCOLN’S GHOST: Houdini’s War on Spiritualism and the Dark Conspiracy Against the American Presidency by Brad Ricca
Blending Abraham Lincoln’s haunted presidency and Harry Houdini’s crusade against spiritualism, Brad Ricca introduces this well-researched and enchanting mix of history and social commentary, set against a snazzy Jazz Age backdrop.
-
THE DEPARTMENT by Jacqueline Faber
THE DEPARTMENT is over-the-top brilliant and intellectually intriguing, with a concussion-grenade conclusion. It is sure to earn an Anthony Award nomination, likely the Big Kahuna: Best First Novel. -
THE BLACK HIGHWAY by Simon Toyne
Transcending the murder mystery aspect, the plot rockets to the suspense/thriller stratosphere. The pages pulse with tension. THE BLACK HIGHWAY is a diabolically delightful read and highly recommended.
-
RIVER OF LIES by James L’Etoile
The plot has more twists and turns than a California cloverleaf, and the asteroid impact-like conclusion will stun readers.
-
GUMSHOE AFTER MIDNIGHT: A Mortimer Angel Mystery by Rob Leininger
GUMSHOE AFTER MIDNIGHT is a ribald mystery with a message: “Jealousy is a disease. It does nothing but destroy.” The reader gets an investigation body slam, then a sucker-punch finale.
-
THE SECRET BOOK SOCIETY by Madeline Martin
The pacing is as gentle as Lady Duxbury’s soothing tea served in exquisite porcelain. THE SECRET BOOK SOCIETY will be a top choice for book clubs. Listen up, Oprah! -
THE DEEPEST LAKE by Andromeda Romano-Lax
Grab your passport and experience rich descriptions of Guatemala’s mountainous region rivaled only by the intense characterization of those involved in the Casa Eva intrigue.
-
A MURDER IN ZION: A National Park Mystery by Nicole Maggi
Rich descriptions of Zion’s “towering crimson cliffs” enhance the majesty of this mystery.
Ray Palen
- FAIR PLAY by Louise Hegarty
- DON’T LET HIM IN by Lisa Jewell
- THE AWARD by Matthew Pearl
- KING OF ASHES by S. A. Cosby
- WITCHCRAFT FOR WAYWARD GIRLS by Grady Hendrix
- THE SECRET OF SECRETS by Dan Brown
- THE PROVING GROUND: A Lincoln Lawyer Novel by Michael Connelly
- THE LAST DEATH OF THE YEAR: A Hercule Poirot Novel by Sophie Hannah
- THE HOUSE AT DEVIL’S NECK: A Joseph Spector Locked-Room Mystery by Tom Mead
- NEVER FLINCH by Stephen King
- DON’T TELL ME HOW TO DIE by Marshall Karp
- THE LAST WITCH by C. J. Cooke
- THE BUFFALO HUNTER HUNTER by Stephen Graham Jones
- KILL YOUR DARLINGS by Peter Swanson
- THE STARVING SAINTS by Caitlin Starling
- WE ARE ALL GUILTY HERE by Karin Slaughter
- WHAT THE NIGHT BRINGS: A Tom Thorne Novel by Mark Billingham
- ROBERT LUDLUM'S THE BOURNE VENDETTA by Brian Freeman
- HANG ON ST. CHRISTOPHER: A Sean Duffy Novel by Adrian McKinty
- THE GHOST WOODS by C. J. Cooke
- WHISTLE by Linwood Barclay
- EXILES by Mason Coile
- BLOOD LIKE OURS by Stuart Neville
- THE END OF THE WORLD AS WE KNOW IT: New Tales of Stephen King's The Stand edited by Christopher Golden and Brian Keene
-
DEPARTURE 37 by Scott Carson
Norah Piehl
- THE ROAD TO TENDER HEARTS by Annie Hartnett
- NO LESS STRANGE OR WONDERFUL: Essays in Curiosity by A. Kendra Greene
- HISTORY LESSONS by Zoe B. Wallbrook
- MURDERLAND: Crime and Bloodlust in the Time of Serial Killers, by Caroline Fraser
- YOU CAN NEVER DIE: A Graphic Memoir, by Harry Bliss
- SO FAR GONE by Jess Walter
- TILT by Emma Pattee
-
MUTUAL INTEREST by Olivia Wolfgang-Smith
Stuart Shiffman
- BUCKEYE by Patrick Ryan
- THE SEASON: A Fan's Story, by Helen Garner
- THE SILVER STATE by Gabriel Urza
- PRESUMED GUILTY by Scott Turow
- THE ELEMENTS by John Boyne
- NOTHIN' COMES EASY: The Life of Rodney Dangerfield, by Michael Seth Starr
- AMERICAN KINGS: A Biography of the Quarterback by Seth Wickersham
- EMINENT JEWS: Bernstein, Brooks, Friedan, Mailer, by David Denby
- THE LAST MANAGER: How Earl Weaver Tricked, Tormented, and Reinvented Baseball by John W. Miller
-
JUSTICE BATTED LAST: Ernie Banks, Minnie Miñoso, and the Unheralded Players Who Integrated Chicago's Major League Teams, by Don Zminda
Jana Siciliano
- BREAD OF ANGELS: A Memoir by Patti Smith --- an instant classic
- ISOLA by Allegra Goodman --- a truly inspired narrative
- GLIFF by Ali Smith
- NOTHING MORE OF THIS LAND: Community, Power, and the Search for Indigenous Identity, by Joseph Lee --- a history of the Wampanoags on Martha’s Vineyard
- THE SILVER BOOK by Olivia Laing --- any book that builds a noir around Fellini and Pasolini has to be a new fave
- TONI AT RANDOM: The Iconic Writer’s Legendary Editorship by Dana A. Williams --- I have so much love for anything Toni Morrison
- THE PHOEBE VARIATIONS by Jane Hamilton
- THE MÖBIUS BOOK by Catherine Lacey
- JANE AUSTEN'S BOOKSHELF: A Rare Book Collector's Quest to Find the Women Writers Who Shaped a Legend by Rebecca Romney --- a fascinating look at other female writers from my favorite "Pawn Stars" consultant
-
WILD WEST VILLAGE: Not a Memoir (Unless I Win an Oscar, Die Tragically, or Score a Country #1) by Lola Kirke --- she’s on a roll with this, a new album and her star turn in Sinners
Philip Zozzaro
- MOB QUEEN by Erin Bledsoe
- LITTLE VIC AND THE GREAT MAFIA WAR by Larry McShane
- FAGIN THE THIEF by Allison Epstein
- DEATH AT THE WHITE HART by Chris Chibnall
- THE CALIFORNIANS by Brian Castleberry
- VANISHING DAUGHTERS by Cynthia Pelayo
- THE ACID QUEEN: The Psychedelic Life and Counterculture Rebellion of Rosemary Woodruff Leary by Susannah Cahalan
- MY NEXT BREATH: A Memoir by Jeremy Renner
- ROBERT SHAW: An Actor’s Life on the Set of Jaws and Beyond, by Christopher Shaw Myers
- MISSISSIPPI BLUE 42 by Eli Cranor
- THE OCCULT ELVIS: The Mystical and Magical Life of the King, by Miguel Conner
- EL DORADO DRIVE by Megan Abbott
- THE CARPOOL DETECTIVES: A True Story of Four Moms, Two Bodies, and One Mysterious Cold Case by Chuck Hogan
- SPEAK TO ME OF HOME by Jeanine Cummins
- BUCKLEY: The Life and the Revolution That Changed America by Sam Tanenhaus
- THE MACABRE by Kosoko Jackson
- LORNE: The Man Who Invented Saturday Night Live by Susan Morrison
- BLOOD LIKE OURS by Stuart Neville
- CROOKS: A Novel About Crime and Family by Lou Berney
- JOAN CRAWFORD: A Woman's Face by Scott Eyman


