Skip to main content

Bookreporter Reviewers' Favorite Books of 2025

Reviewer Picks

Bookreporter Reviewers' Favorite Books of 2025

Recently we asked our reviewers to provide us with a list of their favorite books from 2025. Included is a mix of fiction and nonfiction titles, all published for the first time this year. We always love hearing which books resonated the most with them! Please note that due to personal and professional commitments, some reviewers were not able to participate in this feature.

 

Kate Ayers


 

Curtis Edmonds

  • 1929: Inside the Greatest Crash in Wall Street History — and How it Shattered a Nation, by Andrew Ross Sorkin
  • THE MARTIANS: The True Story of an Alien Craze that Captured Turn-of-the-Century America, by David Baron
  • THE GALES OF NOVEMBER: The Untold Story of the Edmund Fitzgerald, by John U. Bacon
  • ANGEL DOWN by Daniel Kraus
  • MIDNIGHT ON THE POTOMAC: The Last Year of the Civil War, the Lincoln Assassination, and the Rebirth of America, by Scott Ellsworth
  • EVERYBODY WANTS TO RULE THE WORLD EXCEPT ME by Django Wexler
  • LETHAL PREY: A Lucas Davenport and Virgil Flowers Novel by John Sandford
     

 

Sarah Rachel Egelman


 

Megan Elliott


 

Harvey Freedenberg


 

Ron Kaplan


 

Pamela Kramer


 

Bronwyn Miller


 

Rebecca Munro


 

L. Dean Murphy

Dean's List

  • THE DEPARTMENT by Jacqueline Faber
    THE DEPARTMENT is over-the-top brilliant and intellectually intriguing, with a concussion-grenade conclusion. It is sure to earn an Anthony Award nomination, likely the Big Kahuna: Best First Novel.

  • THE BLACK HIGHWAY by Simon Toyne 
    Transcending the murder mystery aspect, the plot rockets to the suspense/thriller stratosphere. The pages pulse with tension. THE BLACK HIGHWAY is a diabolically delightful read and highly recommended.
     
  • RIVER OF LIES by James L’Etoile 
    The plot has more twists and turns than a California cloverleaf, and the asteroid impact-like conclusion will stun readers.
  • GUMSHOE AFTER MIDNIGHT: A Mortimer Angel Mystery by Rob Leininger
    GUMSHOE AFTER MIDNIGHT is a ribald mystery with a message: “Jealousy is a disease. It does nothing but destroy.” The reader gets an investigation body slam, then a sucker-punch finale.
     
  • THE SECRET BOOK SOCIETY by Madeline Martin 
    The pacing is as gentle as Lady Duxbury’s soothing tea served in exquisite porcelain. THE SECRET BOOK SOCIETY will be a top choice for book clubs. Listen up, Oprah!
  • THE DEEPEST LAKE by Andromeda Romano-Lax
    Grab your passport and experience rich descriptions of Guatemala’s mountainous region rivaled only by the intense characterization of those involved in the Casa Eva intrigue.
     
  • A MURDER IN ZION: A National Park Mystery by Nicole Maggi
    Rich descriptions of Zion’s “towering crimson cliffs” enhance the majesty of this mystery.
     

 

Ray Palen


 

Norah Piehl


 

Stuart Shiffman


 

Jana Siciliano


 

Philip Zozzaro