This contest period's winners were Carol H. from Simpsonville, SC; Holly B. from Phoenix, AZ; and Sandy M. from Dayton, OH. Each received a copy of THE FIRST TIME I SAW HIM by Laura Dave and SKYLARK by Paula McLain.
Rose
The Christmas Tree Farm by Laurie Gilmore
Kira has moved to Dream Harbor and purchased a Christmas tree farm, partly to escape the heartache of being separated from her twin sister. However, she knows that her sister needed to push out on her own to become her own person. She meets Bennett whose ego is still bruised from a breakup with a previous girlfriend. He loves to fix things, but Kira is adamant she can handle things on her own. When a winter storm strands them together, they can't hide their desire for each other. But, it has to be just a fling, so Kira tells him to leave. But, they are meant to be together - it is a romance! I found this to be enjoyable but not great, just okay.
Rose
The Perfect Hosts by Heather Gudenkauf
It was supposed to be a celebration. The gender reveal party for Madeline and Wes Drake's baby was in full swing, when a bomb explodes killing one of the guests and injuring others. Agent Jamie Saldano has moved to Wyoming, against his wife's wishes, to follow a career promotion, but also to come to terms with his sister's disappearance years earlier.
As Jamie investigates the case, all is not as it seems. The Drakes and the Saldanos are connected in ways Jamie didn't realize. There is a lot of physical abuse mentioned in this novel, and also promiscuity and betrayal. The twists were a bit surprising, but this still wasn't my favorite of Gudenkauf's novels, although it was still good.
Jackie
Blood Moon by Sandra Brown
Not sure where Blood Moon came from.
Allison
A Witch's Guide to Magical Inkeeping by Sangu Mandanna
This was a magical delight.
Mary
Eight Years of Lies by Lisa Hall
Kept me guessing all the way through. Even to last page. I want a sequel.
Lynn
Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie
I had forgotten how much I enjoy Agatha Christie mysteries. This was a book club selection. We had a great discussion on many points in the book. You can never go wrong with an Agatha Christie mystery.
Luella
Missing Child by Patricia McDonald
This had a difficult subject and was a tear-jerker. It had many twists and turns to keep you guessing.
Jill
Home Front by Kristin Hannah
I love Kristin Hannah as an author, but this was not one of my favorites of hers. I still really enjoyed the book and thought it was very moving.
Jeanne
The Weekend Crashers by Jamie Brenner
THE WEEKEND CRASHERS by Jamie Brenner is a delightful, well written, entertaining read about a mother and daughter who go on a weekend knitting retreat. It is full of family drama, mother-daughter and father-son relationships. The author did a great job creating and developing the characters. I enjoyed reading this from cover to cover.
Teresa
Coming Up Short by Robert B. Reich
If you’re a history and politics junkie like me, this is a book you may enjoy. Reich recalls what was going on in the world, particularly in the U.S., during his 80 years of life. Our perspectives early on were different, as he was in college when I was in junior high school, but overall it stirred a lot of memories, while giving me insights and background I appreciated. Why 4 stars? It’s so long!
Teresa
The Shortest Way Home by Miriam Parker
I always enjoy a book that takes the reader on a journey as the main character “finds” herself.
Elizabeth
The Widow by John Grisham
Very interesting.
Julie
Nobody’s Girl by Virginia Roberts Giuffre
Even if you aren't in the right headspace to read this book, please consider buying it in support of Virginia's bravery to take a stand. Our future generations of women are watching us. As she states within the book, “I know this is a lot to take in. The violence. The neglect. The bad decisions. The self-harm. Imagine if a trauma reel like this played in your head all the time, as it does in mine, and not just on the pages of a book you can put down if you need to, just for a moment, to steady your nerves. But please don’t stop reading. I know exactly how to help you get through these tough parts, just as I help myself: by focusing on the present.”
Julie
Broken Country by Clare Leslie Hall
BROKEN COUNTRY broke me. I was completely immersed in this heartbreaking love story from the minute I read very first page. The most atmospheric and character driven novel I’ve read yet this year.
Julie
My Friends by Fredrik Backman
Fredrik Backman has the ability to bring the characters in his books to life in such a way that you feel as if you truly know them, while at the same time achieving a perfect balance between humor and gravity in their story. He captures human emotions in writing like very few authors can do.
There are SO many great lines in this coming-of-age novel about friendship and belonging. I started tabbing them, and soon realized I was tabbing nearly every page. This one’s going to stick with me. Well done!
Nancy
Cape Fever by Nadia Davids
I love a good Gothic suspense story, and CAPE FEVER nails it - with an added depth, portraying 1920's colonial society in Cape Town as experienced by a young Muslim servant. The result is a page-turner, immersive novel with its increasing sense of threat, illuminating not only a specific place and time but also attitudes that persist today.
Julie
A Good Animal by Sara Maurer
"A heart-wrenching coming-of-age novel by a stunning new voice in fiction” is how the synopsis begins and that’s exactly what this novel is. Perhaps it’s because this small town girl grew up in farm country, where everyone looks forward to the county fair. Or maybe it’s the fact that one of my classmate’s was from a family of sheep farmers. My God, this book took my breath away. I was totally captivated by the storyline and fell in love with the well-developed characters. Many thanks to Goodreads and St. Martin’s Press for the opportunity to read an ARC. This one cracked my heart open from the very start.
Jayme
Amity by Nathan Harris
This was an interesting read about a part of history that I knew very little. After the Civil War there was a migration of former slaves to Mexico to carve out a new life. This story centers on a brother and sister who are separated and the struggles that they have trying to reunite.
Jayme
Vera Wong’s Unsolicited Advice for Murderers by Jesse Q. Suntanto
This was a fine, no-brainer book - a bit silly and very unrealistic. I just wish that writers would stop writing 60-year-old women as if we have one foot in the coffin. We are not that old or frumpy.
Pam
The Housemaid by Frieda McFadden
Suspenseful and fast-moving thriller.
jana
The Correspondent by Virginia Evans
Loved, loved this book by a first-time author who weaves into the lives of Sybil through her hand-written letters she sent over her entire life, over 300 I believe.
Wanda
The Seven Daughters of Dupree by Nikesha Elise Williams
This book was hard for me to read, slang language and many times of having to figure out what the characters were talking about. Storyline was good, interesting, so gave a 3-star rating.
Rhonda
Twist by Colum McCann
This book sparked lively discussion in our book group, particularly about the characters. I personally thought it was a slow start and almost put the book down. But I’m glad I read on. I especially liked the message about human impact on the environment and the impact of internet on human relationships. But mostly I liked the character development and trying to discern their motives.
Francisca
People We Meet on Vacation by Emily Henry
Okay romance, friend-to-lovers trope. The kind of light reading that was perfect for my recovery from surgery.
MH
The Winter Sister by Megan Collins
Sylvie returns home to care for her mother who has cancer. Years ago, her older sister was murdered and the crime was never solved though Sylvie has always known Ben, the boyfriend, did it. Now she is confronted with him as well as her unresolved issues with her mother, who became an alcoholic and shut her out after the murder.
Lisa
Sisters of Fortune by Anna Lee Huber
Historical fiction based on the true story of the Fortune sisters, three very different personalities along with their parents and younger brother Charlie. The opulence of the ship was amazing to me as well as the courage of the crew.
LisaMarie
Broken Country by Clare Leslie Hall
This book went beyond any expectations I had. The characters stayed with you even long after you put down the book. I still wonder how they all are today. It had love, mystery, murder, past trauma - it was just so wonderful. You’re always excited when you find that one gem of a book when you think about those characters long after you’ve read the book.
Denise
By Any Other Name by Jodi Picoult
An interesting look into the works of Shakespeare. Did he in fact really write his plays and poems? Is it possible he fronted others work since they were not allowed to be known as writers or play writers? Told as a dual narrative from two women's perspectives, bouncing between two time periods, the stories unfold answering these possibilities with very believable angles. Each woman experiences being silenced by societal restrictions. You witness the struggle to be seen and how they each try to overcome the hurdles thrown at them by prejudice of being a woman in a man's world. At times a very dark read that fits the past era realistically, even when it is heartbreaking. And it appears history continues.
Aimee
Finding Me by Viola Davis
One of the best memoirs I've read. I would recommend people choose the audiobook to hear Viola narrate her own incredible, moving story, and appreciate her Grammy winning performance.
Geri
This Tender Land by William Kent Krueger
By far the best storytelling I have ever read. Pure Americana, so much tenderness, thoughtfulness and genuine character development in this book. He’s a master. Everyone should read this book.
EILEEN
West With Giraffes by Lynda Rutledge
A good travel story with a good story about interesting characters and a giraffe being moved across the United States.
Janet
A Little Christmas Spirit by Sheila Roberts
Perfect Christmasy story.
Shaorn
James by Percival Everett
Although often touted as a companion read to HUCKLEBERRT FINN, this book is a stand-alone that changed this reader’s perspective about the south of the past. It does make one want to read Mark Twain’s work and see what messages he wanted to portray. It was a quick, deep read.
Kim
Cursed Daughters by Oyinkan Braithwaite
This is a book that will stick with me for awhile. There is a lot in there to think about. This will be a great selection for book clubs. It's one of those books that will improve with discussion. There is so to discuss - the curse and how it affects each woman's life, character analysis - so much that I want to discuss and analyze right now, but can't do it here because I don't want to spoil the book for anyone. The book is not for everyone, particularly those that just want a quick, easy read. But if you like books that are slow to develop and make you think, this one may be for you!
Sharon
The House Without Windows by Barbara Newhall Follett
I found this book from the recommendation of Patti Callahan Henry, who used it as inspiration for her latest novel, THE STORY SHE LEFT BEHIND. The author of THE HOUSE WITHOUT WINDOWS was only nine years old the (the book was finally published when she was 12), and the book is supposedly semi-autobiographical. I loved the main character's freedom to be herself and the vivid descriptions of nature. It reminded me of books I read when I was a child, and it made me feel my own childlike freedom emerge as I read. Just a beautiful, magical book.
Emily
Mother Mary Comes to Me by Arundhati Roy
Beautiful writing. However, her story, while riveting, is depressing. Sadly, the author’s personality is a reflection of her mother’s.
Elizabeth
My Friends by Fredik Backman
This was a heartwarming story about friendship, but a little too repetitive for me.
Sandy
Not Quite Dead Yet by Holly Jackson
Another who dunnit that I couldn't figure out. Jet is the daughter of one of the wealthiest families in Woodstock, Vermont. She thinks she has plenty of time to begin her life. Until the night of Halloween when she is violently attacked by an unseen intruder. Doctors are certain that within a week the injury will trigger a deadly aneurysm. So she has one week to solve her own murder. As her condition deteriorates she only has her childhood friend, Billy for help. She is absolutely determined to finally finish something.
Lynda
My Beloved by Jan Karon
A delightful story that takes place in a small mountain town, Mitford, NC. It meanders from one colorful character to another as Father Tim's missing Christmas gift, a heartfelt love letter to his "beloved" wife makes the rounds. Fans of Karon's Mitford series will enjoy this warm, funny and all too relatable latest book.
Cheryl
Theo of Golden by Allen Levi
Such a wonderful book !! Kindness and community can change lives. Wish there was an artist and coffee shop in my town!!
Barbara
The Instrumentalist by Harriet Constable
This is an endearing story with a compelling plot, especially for anyone with knowledge of classical music.
Barbara
A Town Like Alice by Nevil Shute
Although this book was published in 1950, it reads like a very modern story. The plot is fascinating (based on real-life events) and the writing is great. It surprised me in very pleasant ways.
Barbara
The Names by Florence Knapp
The concept of this book is very unique. It took me many pages until I caught on to the author's intent. Once I did, I really wanted to reread from the beginning. It's three versions of the same story.
Jayme
12 Ways to Kill Your Family at Christmas by Natasha Bache
That was a fun holiday murder mystery similar in premise to Agatha Christie's AND THEN THERE WERE NONE. My family better be good this Christmas - I took notes.
Rose
It's a Christmas Thing by Janet Dailey
A romance set at Christmastime. Dr. Rush is a vet and is still sad over the loss of the little girl he thought was his own, before his wife admitted that the child was another man's. Tracy is still mourning the death of her husband. When Tracy calls Rush to help her with a sick cat, he realizes he definitely has a crush on her. Then, Rush is asked to care for Clara, the young child, when her parents go off on a cruise. She still calls him Daddy. Tracy also gets involved in caring for the child. Together Rush and Tracy overcome their feelings of loss and grief, and build a family. Nice, clean romance with a happy ending. Not too deep, but a nice story.
Tori
Atmosphere by Taylor Jenkins Reid
Empowering. Aspiring. This book made me experience an abundance of emotions. I couldn’t put it down. I fell in love with all of the characters.
Nadine
Upon the Corner of the Moon: A Tale of the Macbeths by Valerie Nieman
Superbly researched, this historical novel follows Macbeth and Gruach (future Lady Macbeth) from childhood to their engagement in Volume 1. Besides showing what Scotland in the 1100s was like, you understand the political, cultural, and social life was which influenced the main characters and understanding what Shakespeare used in writing the play "Macbeth".
will
Skylark by Paula McLain
Interesting story and title.
Elizabeth
Wild Dark Shore by Charlotte McConaghy
Unique, tragic story set in a remote corner of the Earth and beautifully told.
Tiffany
She Didn't See It Coming by Shari Lapena
Lots of twists and turns, keeps you guessing.
Laura
The Compound by Aisling Rawle
This a book set in a dystopian future. The compound is the setting for a reality show. They start out with minimal supplies. Ten men and ten women competing together and individually for better and better prizes. Lily is the narrator and she knows she doesn’t have much to offer but her beauty and she’s hoping to win to save her from a life she doesn't like. It was pretty good. The premise is interesting.
Joanne
The Correspondent by Virginia Evans
Thoroughly enjoyed the book. The art of letter writing has certainly declined in recent years. It was nice to see how Sybil connected with everyone through her letters.
Rose
Like Family by Erin O. White
I read this due to the glowing reviews it received from several authors. For me, not so much. I didn't like the families or feel invested in their stories. It follows several families and their relationships with each other. Two of the couples are gay, one is heterosexual. A man who had a relationship and child with one of the lesbians years earlier has died and this throws all their lives into turmoil as they work through their relationships and how they relate to each other.
Tessa
The Honeymoon Cottage by Lori Foster
Lovely romance between a wedding planner specializing in “country-chic” celebrations, and the big brother of her newest client who knows what he wants for himself and for his little sister. Small-town vibe with colorful supporting characters.
Beth
Think Twice by Harlan Coben
After all these years (since sometime in the 1990s I think), Harlan Coben's thrillers are still full of mysteries and snappy dialogue, and they still absorb me and keep me up at night. In THINK TWICE, Coben returns to his long-running Myron Bolitar series. It begins with Myron trying to locate his former basketball rival Greg, who he thought was dead. The police are looking for Greg because they think he committed a crime. That one mystery leads to several others. Reading this book was just like old times for me. For a while there I thought I was going to hate to read the end of this book. Read it and you'll see what I mean. Now, though, I just look forward to more.
Rose
Band of Sisters by Lauren Willig
This novel relies on details the author found about a group of women from Smith College who went overseas to assist the French civilians after Germany destroyed their communities during the first World War. These women formed the Smith College Relief Unit and traveled to Europe not knowing what they would face. They brought hospital care and compassion to the community and also had to learn to manage their friendships. Kate was upset to find that her friend Emme helped pay her way, causing a rift in their friendship. Some of the women experience both love and heartache, while working in harsh conditions at times. A story of friendship during wartime. I didn't know about this group and was glad to learn about these women.
Kimberley
The Measure by Nikki Erlick
Without giving away any of the story, this novel is a life lesson for all. Eight characters cross paths because of unforeseen circumstances. Their destiny, their future and their lives have been predetermined. The world is split in half. It’s a page-turner and a must-read.
Sean
Cold People by Tom Rob Smith
I loved Tom Rob Smith's CHILD 44 and SECRET SPEECH novels involving murder thriller/historical fiction. He changes genres here and its a huge misstep. I like science fiction and was hoping for this to read somewhat like THE MARTIAN by Andy Weir where hard science is used to get out of an incredible problem. And it could of have been...but then things get ridiculous and ridiculously written. At times this reads like a YA novel. There are plot holes a plenty and the pacing is awful. There is a good novel hidden somewhere in this idea - survivors from across the globe trying to make a go of it in Antarctica - but it derailed quickly. Most of the characters were cliches or lifeless. It's so hard to believe this was written by the same author.
Rose
The Librarians by Sherry Thomas
A mix of murder, librarians, crypto, secrets, and a lot of mystery abound in this new novel. The four librarians all have a complicated past and are now involved in an investigation when several patrons are found dead in the library. There is confusion about feelings, mysteries about past relationships, and of course, the murder. A good mystery with lots of characters.
Rose
The Boy from the Sea by Garrett Carr
When a baby is found in a small town in Ireland, Ambrose wants to adopt him. He convinces his wife that they should keep him. Ambrose is a fisherman and names the child Brendan. The child is also known as the boy from the sea. When the couple's other son, Declan, goes to school, he doesn't want people to know that he and Brendan are brothers. There is a bit of jealousy and also competition for their father's affection. This is a moving story of family and acceptance.
Rose
Bring Me Home for Christmas by Robyn Carr
A cute, predictable romance. Becca believes her law school boyfriend is going to pop the question soon, but she isn't sure she is over her ex, Denny. They had been inseparable, but she believes he left her, choosing war over her love. She didn't realize how broken Denny was over his mother's illness and his mental state at the time. She refused to take him back when he asked. But now, she needs to be sure. So, she convinces her brother to let her tag along on his guy hunting trip. Her impulsiveness causes her to have an accident where she is injured. Denny steps in to help her and she knows she isn't over him. In addition to Denny, Becca is enamored with the small town, the community, esp. the children who need her.
Rose
The Matzah Ball by Jean Meltzer
When the daughter of a prominent rabbi is a best-selling author of Christmas novels, she uses a pen name and can't admit it to her parents. She also has never gotten over her childhood crush that she met at summer camp. Now years after camp, Rachel and Jacob meet again. Rachel's publisher has decided they want her to write a Hanukkah romance, and Rachel decides she needs to attend the Matzah Ball that Jacob is planning. There is a lot of misunderstanding, hidden hurts as well as physical pain, but eventually Jacob and Rachel express their truths to each other, helped along by friends and family. I enjoyed this romance.
Rose
The Heartbreak Hotel by Ellen O'Clover
After being dumped by her long-time boyfriend, Louisa doesn't want to leave the home they rented in Estes Park, CO. However, she can't afford it, so she concocts a plan to ask the landlord, Henry, for permission to make it a B&B for heartbroken people, as a place to come and heal. The Comeback Inn becomes a place of refuge, and when Henry reveals why it is difficult for him to let go of the house, it is a heartbreaking reason. Both Louisa and Henry need to come to terms with their heartbreak, and learn to be honest with each other. A really nice romance with some heavy issues.
Anita
All the Sinners Bleed by S. A. Cosby
This book was very disappointing. It got rave reviews, so I looked forward to reading it. However, it was very disturbing and depressing. It's about White men in the south who murdered Black children. It was too violent for my taste, and there were so many characters I had trouble keeping track of them all.
Jane
An Amish Second Chance Romance by Rachel J. Good
It has been some time since I read one of Rachel's books, but I have always loved her books. Gossip not only destroys person it is against but person who shreds it as well. Cathy is an excellent cook and bakes donuts at a market stand. People in the community avoid her because of gossip. But no one knows what hurts she has been through in her life growing up. God works through Mrs. Vandenberg helping others. She seems to know what people need. Cathy's nephew receives bad news. He needs Cathy to take care of his two boys while he receives treatment. She approaches Myron to help her know how to do it. Myron was taking care of his brother's boy. Gossip, forgiveness, overcoming fear are the themes in this book.
Francisca
Christmas With Anne by L. M. Montgomery
This is a collection of short stories set around the Christmas holidays. It begins with our lovely Anne Shirley and an early Christmas with Marila and Matthew, and the “puffy sleeves” fashion trend. Most of the other stories do not involve Anne, but they are all heartwarming and charming. And isn’t that what the holidays are all about?
Debbie
A Slowly Dying Casue by Elizabeth George
Elizabeth George writes an extremely detailed novel that covers over 600 pages. Elizabeth does not spurn out a novel a year, but spends years in research and fine-tuning her story. The reader slowly navigates this extensive and well-written story. The characters jump to life and each individual depicts an extraordinary person. The setting transports the reader to the English countryside, and Elizabeth points out the delicate balance of tin-streaming. Can a marriage between a middle-aged man of forty-three and a young girl of eighteen survive? Elizabeth George skillfully gives Michael’s narrative on this ill-fated romance. Michael presents a character as a stupid and ignorant man who believes his young wife loves him.
Rose
Sunburned by Katherine Wood
3.5 rounded to 4 stars. The past comes back to haunt you! Audrey is called to the island of St. Barth's by her former flame, Tyson. They were together until she caught him cheating on her. Now, he is threatening to expose her past unless she can determine who is sending him threatening letters. Tyson has become a billionaire as well as paranoid over the years. Audrey feels she can't say no, and agrees to help him. After a foot surfaces in the Everglades, Tyson and Audrey both know they have a connection to the missing person to whom the foot belongs. It is a secret they have kept for years. Several people are suspects, and Audrey must determine who before another person dies. A decent mystery wrapped in buried secrets.
Rose
Colin Gets Promoted and Dooms the World by Mark Waddell
This book has everything I don't like: doom, demons, jealousy, and the possibiliity of armaggedon. It just wasn't for me. There were some good parts - friendship and love connections, but overall, I just wasn't into the whole destroy the world theme. Yes, I know it is in the title, but I was hoping for something more humorous. Instead I got employees competing for promotions, demons and warring factions, demon eaters, and disappearing people. Sorry, but I wasn't a fan.
Gerry
Before the Coffee Gets Cold by Toshikazu Kawaguchi
A magical coffee house, with one special chair, and if a patron sits in it, it's possible to travel back to the past. There are many rules, one of the most important being that traveling to the past will not change the present. But perhaps it's enough to change the heart of the traveler... This book was interesting, but written in a very repetitive style than made the story drag a bit. Interconnected characters were introduced and reintroduced, and snippets of their lives revealed in the different stories woven together in this novel. Not a bad book at all, but not one that prompts me to move on to others in this series.
Gerry
The Christmas Bookshop by Jenny Colgan
Though I found it too predictable and treacly, this light holiday romance had one benefit: it introduced me to the city of Edinburgh, Scotland, and convinced me I must add it to my travel bucket list.
Gerry
Delta Epiphany: Robert F. Kennedy in Mississippi by Ellen B. Meacham
Though a bit dry at times, this account of Robert F. Kennedy’s work to combat poverty and hunger in Mississippi and other rural areas was a worthwhile read. I can’t help but imagine how different our country might be today if RFK had not been killed, but instead had won election to the Presidency in 1968.
Gerry
Life, and Death, and Giants by Ron Rindo
Gabriel was special from birth: he weighed 18 pounds at birth and continued to grow through his childhood until he surpassed 8 feet in height as a young adult. He achieved typical developmental milestones early, and demonstrated unusual strength, speed, and agility that attracted the attention of coaches in a variety of sports. While his conservative Amish grandparents sought to protect him from the temptations of the "English" world, they could not do so forever, and Gabriel had to choose whether to remain in their world of prayer, simplicity, and respect for the natural world or to move out and explore the very different world outside their community. A compelling story with a remarkable and touching conclusion, this is one I recommend.
Liz
100 Rules for Living to 100 by Dick Van Dyke
Tom Bergeron is the narrator of this quirky book by Dick Van Dyke. Mr. Bergeron does an excellent job relaying the anecdotes of Dick Van Dyke's life. Some of the stories are a bit sad, others funny and most are very poignant. The only improvement I would suggest would be if Dick Van Dyke had these vignettes published in the order of his life, instead of jumping back and forth in different time periods and his life partners.
Gerry
Eleanore of Avignon by Elizabeth DeLozier
Set in 14th century Avignon, this is the story of Eleanore, the daughter of a healer and midwife. Unwilling to bend to the restrictions placed on women of her time, Eleanore used the skills she had learned from her mother to become a skilled herbalist and midwife and used her talents to persuade a physician/surgeon to take her on as his apprentice. When the Black Death arrived in Europe, Surgeon Guigo convinced Pope Clement VI to temporarily suspend the ban on autopsies in order to allow surgeons to dissect the bodies of the dead in order to better understand, and perhaps find a cure for, this deadly disease. The novel includes relevant themes of female strength in the face of obstacles, superstition and scapegoating, and faith vs. science.
Gerry
Kin by Tayari Jones
4-1/2 stars. KIN is the story of two Black women, as close as sisters from early childhood, coming of age in the South in the late 1950s to early 1960s. Niecey and Annie called themselves “cradle friends” and shared everything as girls, with never a secret between them. But as young women, their lives followed different paths, even as they remained in frequent contact. I very much enjoyed following the well-developed characters through their ups and downs during a challenging time in our country's history. The differences in the two women's lives made for interesting, if bittersweet, reading. A final chapter felt a bit tacked-on, and I was surprised when it ended the novel rather than starting a new section.
Gerry
What Child Is This by Rhys Bowen
A sweet story about a young couple during the London Blitz. When their block is hit with incendiary bombs, Maggie and Jack are suddenly homeless on Christmas Eve. Feeling overwhelmed and claustrophobic in the underground, Maggie impulsively pulls Jack onto a train that takes them to Hyde Park. Seeking warmth and shelter, the stumble upon a large and apparently empty home, its door standing open. They enter and begin to settle in for the night, when suddenly they're confronted by a small boy whose presence turns out to be just the first of several Christmas blessings, making this their most memorable Christmas yet.
Gerry
The Christmas Train by David Baldacci
A romance wrapped around a mystery, all set on a cross-country train from DC to LA. Interesting factoids about Mark Twain, supposedly an ancestor of the main character, added to the story.
Holly
Heart the Lover by Lily King
Poignant coming-of-age story of Cassie in college in the ‘80s, caught in a love triangle with two smart boys. The decisions she makes have long-spanning repercussions. The themes of young love and regret figure heavily, but also acceptance and redemption. This book will mess you up inside a bit, but it’s worth it.
Rose
I Feel Bad About My Neck: And Other Thoughts on Being a Woman by Nora Ephron
This is a very funny memoir from Nora Ephron reflecting on many things that happen to women as they age. Some essays are about appearance, others are about love and family. They range from funny to melancholy, especially the ones where she talks about divorce. I enjoyed the stories and the settings, and thought she was spot-on in her observances. I loved this book, but also felt sad that this talented woman left this world much too soon.
Gabriel
Bad Dream by Nicole Maines
I have not seen the Supergirl show from which this character originated. I imagine this story is more impactful as a prequel rather than a starting point for Nia’s story. Without that outside context, parts of the story, particularly the ending, felt rushed. The introduction of and subsequent conflict with the antagonist, as well as Nia’s return home and family drama, could have used more breathing room.
I don’t think I’m the right audience to get the most out of this – it’s got a lot of the standard YA coming-of-age elements that didn’t really stand out to me. I did enjoy the incorporation of ballroom culture, brief though it was, and Nia and Maeve’s fraying sibling dynamic.
Rose
Eight Dates and Nights by Becky Aldredge
Really cute YA romance set around Hanukkah. Hannah visits her grandmother on a farm in Texas over the winter break of her senior year of high school. She has college on her mind, and really doesn't want to spend time mucking out horse stalls. Hannah felt that her grandmother didn't outwardly celebrate being Jewish. When they go into town, Hannah meets Noah and his grandfather at the deli, and Hannah is excited that she has a Jewish connection. She helps out at the deli, and Noah offers to give her eight magical dates. But, Hannah has to return to NY and she doesn't think it will work out. What follows is truly magical.
Sweet story of family, friends, and young love.
Lynda
The Housemaid by Freida McFadden
I understand why the series of three psychological thrillers, starting with THE HOUSEMAID, gets rave reviews, and I and can't wait to read the other two.
Rose
Next Time Will Be Our Turn by Jesse Q. Sutanto
A young girl, Izzy, and her family are celebrating Christmas when the matriarch, the grandmother, Magnolia, enters the party with another woman and it is obvious they are romantically involved. While the family is disgusted by this, Izzy secretly wonders about the relationship as she is wondering about her own sexual preferences. Magnolia proceeds to tell her life story to Izzy, telling her of the love of her life, Ellery, a woman she met when she traveled to California from Jakarta. Falling in love with Ellery in the early 2000s, and the subsequent decisions she needed to make, was a story she needed Izzy to hear. The novel's current year is around 2050, so it is disheartening that acceptance of same sex relationships is still taboo.
Rose
Slow Noodles: A Cambodian Memoir of Love, Loss, and Family Recipes by Chantha Nguon
A memoir of a Cambodian woman whose family had to flee their homeland, escaping genocide. The family went through so many horrific events and several of the family members died due to poor medical care, or refusal of it. The author tries to hold onto her culture by recounting her mother's recipes. I was amazed at the perseverance of the author as she lived through terrible conditions, refugee camps, moving to various countries, while eventually working for aid services to help others. Amazing story of resilience.
Donna
Three Days In June by Anne Tyler
This novel focuses on a mother and the days leading up to the daughter’s wedding. A whirlwind of emotions and memories come to light, including forgiveness. The novel involved several humorous moments with the mother, the bride and the bride’s father as the central characters. The book was short and a quick read. I have read most of Anne Tyler’s books but this book seemed flat to me and not up to Tyler’s standards.
Barbara
Theo of Golden by Allen Levi
Absolutely lovely. I savored it.
Barbara
Take My Hand by Dolen Perkins-Valdez
An incredibly important story, very well told.
Barbara
Palaver by Bryan Washington
I've decided that while I appreciate his talent, Bryan Washington's style is just not my cup of tea.
Barbara
Playground by Richard Powers
I will never look at or think of the sea the same way. Richard Powers is a master.
Barbara
The Correspondent by Virginia Evans
I was completely captivated, and I miss the characters now that the book is done.
Liz
Big Lies in a Small Town by Diane Chamberlain
Morgan Christopher has been sent to prison for something she didn’t do not do, but has willingly taken the blame for who she thought was the love of her life. When she is offered a mysterious job to restore a painting, something she has no experience in doing, she jumps at the chance because it will get her paroled. The story is told in two different time frames, by two different people, several decades apart. This makes it difficult for the reader to really get invested into the story. While parts of the story were interesting, others were predictable - for instance, the primary male and female character find love with each other. I felt there was no closure in the way the ending was written. It left me unsatisfied.
Kimberley
Eternal by Lisa Scottoline
This historical fiction follows three school friends living in Rome just on the brink of entering WWII.
Their friendship is tested as it becomes politically unsafe to be together. It’s a story of unbelievable bravery and resilience. Their journey is heart-wrenching and the reader is reminded the nothing about war or its conclusion is romantic. Beautifully written and well researched, this is a must-read.
Sara
The Correspondent by Virginia Evans
Just an excellent story told through the letters the main character writes over her life.
Beth
Crisis in the Red Zone by Richard Preston
Richard Preston's nonfiction is not only interesting - it is as unputdownable as any thriller. This was true for THE HOT ZONE and for THE DEMON IN THE FREEZER. Now I can say it again for his CRISIS IN THE RED ZONE. The book begins back in 1976 when the Ebola crisis began in Africa. Preston went over this in more detail in THE HOT ZONE. Now fast forward to 2014. The Ebola crisis that most of us thought was under control is rearing its ugly head again in Africa. We don't just hear the scientific facts about Ebola. Preston personalizes it. The people working on the front lines with this monster, the doctors, the nurses, the ambulance drivers, the gravediggers, the scientists, the epidemiologists, etc., are the story. Presto.
Rose
Violet Thistlewaite Is Not a Villain Anymore by Emily Krempholtz
This is a fantasy romance. Violet is the Thornwitch, but she doesn't want to be known as that. She has magical powers with plants. She meets an alchemist, Nathaniel, and is attracted to him. When a mysterious blight threatens their community, they must work together to find the cause and save the community. Cute cozy romance.
Rose
Aftertaste by Daria Lavelle
I was expecting more from this book, and I think it started out well. A young boy's father dies shortly after they had an argument. Later, the boy, Kostya, tastes his father's favorite food in his mouth, but isn't eating anything. He decides to unite people with their dead loved ones through food. One of the people he aims to help uses him, and this becomes a big part of the story. Interesting concept, but I thought it went on a bit too long.
Rose
The Phoenix Pencil Company by Allison King
I have a hit or miss record with Reese's book club picks. I would put this in the miss category.
Monica is a coder in college, and she is trying to connect to her grandmother's stories. Her grandmother came to the U. S. from China and has stories of forging pencils. This is a practice I never heard about, and it was a bit gory in my opinion. However, by reforging the pencils, they were able to bring the stories of people to life. This is a bit of coming-of-age, as well as ties to a family with a rich past, as well as caring for the elderly, and the special bond between grandchildren and grandparents. I did learn a bit about the Taiwan/China struggles, but I would not consider this historical fiction, but instead more of a fantasy.
Francisca
Cliff Diver by Carmen Amato
This first entry in the Emilia Cruz Mysteries introduces the reader to our heroine, the first female detective on the Acapulco, Mexico police squad. This is a multi-layered mystery, involving multiple murders, drug cartels, counterfeiting, gambling, sex abuse/trafficking, corrupt officials and a possible romantic relationship for Detective Cruz. There were plenty of red herrings and subplots to keep me guessing as to who murdered whom and why.
shelly
Plain Jane's Secret Admirer by Anne Blackburne
Jane Bontrager's life is rather dull. She works at The Plain Beignet owned by Lizzie and her husband, John, who is also Jane's brother. After a day at work all she has waiting for her at home is her cat named Secret. She would love to be married and start a family. She has always liked Samuel Mast since they were in school but nothing seems to have happened between the two.
Samuel has a secret that even his best friend Ben has been encouraging him to admit to Jane and maybe they can get past it and move on. Sam is shy and decides he will start by leaving little gifts for Jane's cat and sign it secret admirer. Things seem to finally be moving nicely when suddenly a phony "secret admirer" appears and now Jane is scared.
Donna
Water Finds a Way by Meghan Perry
If you’re in the mood for a hidden gem, look no further than WATER FINDS A WAY by Meghan Perry, a gritty, atmospheric debut. The characters are so richly drawn, complex and flawed. In order to move forward, they’ll have to make peace with the past, and learn to open up to one another. It was tough to say goodbye to these characters. An absolutely beautiful read.
Sean
The Guest List by Lucy Foley
Like all Lucy Foley books, this was entertaining as hell and probably had too many twists. The premise is simple, a character will be murdered and readers have to figure out who, by whom, and why. Foley throws so many red herrings at you, possibly too many, that readers are always kept guessing. I like twists but there is a limit. The author really shines with her dialogue as I felt characters spoke like real people. She creates interesting characters and deftly connected the dots. The book is dark and troubling but I enjoyed the read. Overall, a lightning fast thrill ride.
Rose
In the Family Way by Laney Katz Becker
A quick read about girls and women in the early 1960s before Roe v. Wade was law and when the pill wasn't readily available. It was also a time when women couldn't get credit on their own, and divorce was frowned upon. Also, sex wasn't always discussed openly with children, so sometimes young girls didn't really understand how one got pregnant. But, in many families, an unplanned pregnancy, or one to an unmarried girl, was a cause for shame. I enjoyed the stories in this novel, and how one of the girls handled her pregnancy and the birth of her child. An enjoyable read, very relevant at this time since Roe v. Wade was overturned.
Rose
Her Deadly Game by Robert Dugoni
Oh, how exciting to begin another Dugoni series with a female protagonist! Keera Duggan is flawed, but she is a good attorney. Her father, an alcoholic, is causing her problems. When a wealthy investor, Vince La Russa, contacts her to defend him in the murder of his wife, she vows to be the lead on the case. Vince swears he didn't do it. His wife, injured in a horse-riding accident, was in a wheelchair and murdered by a bullet. The scene was odd, and Keera tries to unravel it. She is getting odd emails that point her in a particular direction. I loved this first book in the series and can't wait to read more!
Lesley
Ladies in Waiting by Eloisa James, Sarah MacLean, et al.
I would gladly give some of the stories in this collection 5 stars! Just in time for Jane Austen's 250th birthday, the short stories and novellas in this book explore what could have been, giving life to some of Jane Austen's most neglected characters, Miss Bates (Emma, young Margaret (Sense and Sensibility), Lydia (Pride and Prejudice) to name a few.
Rose
After She Wrote Him by Sulari Gentill
Interesting story about an author, Madeleine, who becomes so involved in her books that she imagines a love affair with her main male character, Edward. Her husband, Hugh, a doctor, becomes distant from her, at least in her mind. As Madeleine imagines more conversations with Edward, he becomes more real to her. An interesting take on a mystery writer's experience. A bit odd, but you do want to know what will happen.
Rose
Fault Lines by Emily Itami
A Japanese wife and mom, Mizuki, is contemplating her life. She and her husband Tatzu seem to be drifting apart. When she meets Kiyoshi she is excited by him and starts to wonder what her life would be like with him. But, she loves being a mom, and knows that she and her husband were once in love, so she is torn between an exciting life and her existing stable life. She reminisces about spending time as an exchange student in the U. S., and how her father encouraged her to apply and go. This is a refreshingly honest book at how a woman considers her choices and the decisions she makes. I really liked it. Great debut.
Rose
I Cheerfully Refuse by Leif Enger
Rainy sets sail on Lake Superior searching for his lost wife, Lark. She loved books, and Rainy had read MOLLY THORN, which comes up frequently. As he searches, he meets a myriad group of people. Once of these is a young girl, Sol, who he helps, getting her away from an abusive man and back to a man she loves as her grandfather. He also helps her to learn to understand letters and start a love of books. The tale was meandering and helped explore a man's grief. I thought it went on a bit too long.
Megan
Beautiful Ugly by Alice Feeney
If you enjoy psychological thrillers filled with secrets, unreliable characters, and jaw-dropping twists, BEAUTIFUL UGLY is a must-read. Alice Feeney once again proves she’s a master at keeping readers guessing until the very end.
Rose
The Christmas You Found Me by Sarah Morgenthaler
Sienna is heartbroken. She has just finalized the divorce from her husband, Micah. Fortunately, she has retained her family ranch, but very few of the assets they shared. Now, her friend, Jess, has posted an advertisement for a Husband for Hire for Sienna. When Guy shows up with his daughter, Emma, who requires a kidney transplant, initially Sienna declines to hire him. But, then she decides she can help them by putting them on her insurance, so she proposes a sham marriage. As they wait for Emma to get a kidney, Sienna is trying to deal with the anger of her ex over her marriage, and also deal with a dying father with dementia. This is a really sweet Christmas story. I cried at the ending.
Rose
Don't Open Your Eyes by Liv Constantine
Annabelle begins having disturbing dreams, typically involving her family being in terrible accidents or her meeting with a mysterious man. When some of these events begin actually happening, her husband, James, asks her to see someone. Later, when her daughter is sent to the hospital after a bad accident, things from Annabelle's past come to light, and her world nearly falls apart. A twisted psychological thriller, with a bit of a surprise twist!
Donna
Before Dorothy by Hazel Gaynor
This is such a fun book. I grew up watching "The Wizard of Oz", so reading about Auntie Em and Uncle Henry was fascinating. Such a fun concept. It also talked about the rise of the Dust Bowl.
Donna
How to Clean Your Life with Sunshine: A women’s fiction novel perfect for fans of heartfelt humor and imperfect heroines by Jenny Hogan
I loved this book. The protagonist, Kira, was running a company to help people organize their homes and lives while Kira was kind of a mess - at home and at love. She has a lot of fun friends, and her relationship with her mother is close and sometimes prickly. A book all woman can enjoy.
Diane
Mona's Eyes by Thomas Schlesser
Wonderful survey of art history intertwined with a sweet grandparent story.
Tessa
Burn for Me by Ilona Andrews
Book One in the Hidden Legacies series takes place in Houston, Texas, but it’s not the Houston we know. In this world, magic rules, and the families who have the most magic are the most powerful. The mayhem and magic is enough plot for anyone, but the romantic tension between “Mad” Rogan and PI Nevada Baylor add some nice spice to the mix.
Donna
Cape Fever by Nadia Davids
Are there any authors, when you see a book described as reminiscent of their work, you NEED to read? For me, one such author is Daphne du Maurier. And, that was the case with CAPE FEVER by Nadia Davids. This Gothic, psychological tale is divided into three parts. The pacing of Part I was slower, setting the background for what was to come. From Part II on, the suspense continued to build, making it unputdownable for me. A fantastic blend of historical fiction and the supernatural.
Sandy
Wild Dark Shore by Charlotte McConaghy
Wild and dark! Dom and his three children are caretakers of a remote island near Antartica. A strange woman washes up on shore and disrupts everything. I couldn't put this one down!!
Rose
Good Spirits by B. K. Borison
This is a cute romance. Nolan, the ghost of Christmas Past, is assigned to Harriet. However, Harriet doesn't have to look back on her life and make amends. They need to figure out why Nolan has been assigned to her. As they travel back in time to examine her life, they realize they have a strong attraction to each other. They also discover what it is that ties them together. Warning, some of the sex scenes are quite descriptive. I enjoyed it for the romance and also for the holiday theme, as well as the Baltimore/Maryland references.
Rose
Behind Every Good Man by Sara Goodman Confino
I really enjoy Confino's books.They make me laugh and they also have a great story. In this novel, Beverly is the perfect wife, making sure the house and children are always perfect for her husband, taking all the stress from him.One day, she shows up to his office and finds him with his secretary. As her life falls apart, she needs a job. It's the 1960s and while her family is well connected, many married women weren't working. She decides to take her revenge by working for Michael who is running for Senate against the candidate that her husband is managing. What follows is a witty story of a political campaign, how to build support, and how to charm voters, while keeping away from scandal. So good, and a joy to escape today's politics!
Rose
Murder on the Marlow Belle by Roibert Thorogood
Judith and friends return to help solve the murder of a man shot and murdered on a ship. As they interview everyone that had been on the ship, they are frustrated as everyone seems to have an alibi for the time of the murder. As they continue to ask questions, they discover a reason for the murder and a fallacy in what was originally believed to be the cause of the murder. Jealousy and past events play a part in the story. The ending is a great lead-in to Book 5! I can't wait to discover what is next.
Rose
The Compound by Aisling Rawle
I am not a fan of reality TV, so this novel set in the near future, where contestants vie to be the last remaining person at The Compound was not for me. I didn't enjoy the backstabbing, the betrayal, the desire for material things. Not sure why this book is getting so many accolades, but it wasn't for me. I felt it was a sad story of excess, consumption, and loneliness.
Rose
Dead & Breakfast by Kat Hillis and Rosiee Thor
A cute vampire/paranormal mystery. Two vampires run a bed and breakfast, and when the mayor is found murdered, they decide to solve the murder. It seems that some of the townspeople are not happy that vampires are "living" among them. There was lots of info about vampires, e.g. they can be out in the sun, but must protect their skin! They eat, they sleep, they don't hang upside down, but perhaps sleep upside down! A fun, queer, paranormal mystery.
Rose
Tell Me Who You Are by Louisa Luna
3.5 rounded to 4 of 5 stars. When a patient, Nathan, tells psychiatrist Dr. Caroline Strange that he is going to murder someone, she realizes that she needs to stop him. A young woman goes missing, and as Dr. Caroline tells her back story, along with Gordon Strange telling his story, you begin to wonder who is reliable in their narrative. The time is getting short for the captured woman, and Dr. Caroline has some secrets, as does Nathan. An eerie thriller.
Rose
Postcards from the Edge by Carrie Fisher
In this semi-autobiographical collection of essays, Suzanne tells of her drug addiction, her life that was perfect until she messed it up, love affairs, poor control and decisions. As I listened to this collection, read by the author, it pained me, knowing that she died much too young. Pressures of being a young Hollywood star and living in the high-pressure world creates an environment where people find it difficult to cope. A raw collection, but with humor and some hope.
Nancy
When I Kill You by B. A. Paris
You won’t be able to read the prologue to WHEN I KILL YOU and not start to feel the terror and fear that Nell is feeling. As you learn Nell’s secrets and about her past, you understand that she has very valid reasons for thinking someone is stalking her and wanting her dead. And then the notebook excerpts begin, and you know that Nell’s life is definitely in danger. The more that is revealed the more the tension ramps up and you will be on the edge of your seat until the very surprising ending.
Luella
Plain Faith by Irene and Ora Jay Eash
A true story of a young family's struggle to leave the Amish. Through tragedy and love they found peace and happiness.
Sandy
So Far Gone by Jess Walter
This book was great!! Going to look for more by Jess Walter.
Christina
The Float Test by Lynn Steger Strong
This book had a good storyline. However, the book structure was a little confusing. It was written from one of the family members perspective, but in some instances it didn’t make sense to me as it seemed to switch to being told by another family member. I found it very confusing and it took away from the story.
Christina
Moderation by Elaine Castillo
This book was just not for me. I enjoyed the sections of the book dealing with Girlie and her family, but when the story delved into the virtual reality, it lost my interest. I thought that the focus on virtual reality was too much of an emphasis. However, if you’re a gamer and into virtual reality, you may enjoy the book. It did make me think more about who is watching the conduct of users of various platforms on the internet. I never thought much about who actually does this and the psychological effects it could have on a person.
Christina
Far and Away by Amy Poeppel
I was looking forward to this book as I really enjoyed the author’s previous book, THE SWEET SPOT. I was not disappointed. This story focused on the lives of two women, one in Dallas, Texas and the other living in Berlin, Germany who, for various reasons, end up swapping residences. This was a story of the women trying to find happiness in their lives and a great story of found family. It is an easy, enjoyable read with an interesting storyline. Similar to her last novel, there are a number of interesting characters introduced in the book and also had several humorous scenes as well. This was another winner from Amy Poeppel and I loved the ending!
Christina
Mrs. Endicott’s Splendid Adventure by Rhys Bowen
This was a very enjoyable read about three women who travel to France in hopes of a better life. They end up in a small village and create a life for themselves and find joy that they have been missing in their lives in England. The book takes place right before and during World War II. There were interesting characters throughout the book and a little romance.
Christina
Buckeye by Patrick Ryan
I just finished BUCKEYE by Patrick Ryan which was just released on September 2nd of this year.
What a story!! This book tells the story of two families in the fictional town of Bonhomie, Ohio over 40 years starting from World War II. The book details the relationship between two married couples.
The book focuses on the secrets kept by the two couples and the effects of them on the couples and their children.
It is a powerful story and covers many different topics important at that time and now in the current day.
The characters were complex and interesting and the drama surrounded “the secrets” kept my attention throughout. It is a heartbreaking tale but well worth the read.
I highly recommend
Christina
Leave Before I Love You by Max Monroe
This was my first Max Monroe book. This was a fun romance novel. I was not expecting the action that took place at the beginning of the book; I thought it really added to my enjoyment of the book. At the beginning of the story, we meet Henry, who is an adventurous, handsome and kind male leading character and Avery, who is a high society girl who spends her time shopping and on hair, makeup, and other cosmetic and beauty services. I really liked Henry but I found Avery to be not a very likeable leading female character. However, I found myself routing for their love story midway through the book. During the novel, the plot reveals more about both of them, and I found myself starting to enjoy her character.
Christina
Wild Dark Shore by Charlotte McConaghy
This was a top read of the year for me. It was so beautifully written. The story of Dom and his three children trying to navigate the loss of their mother and his wife on a remote island in the Antarctic was told from all of their perspectives. The introduction of a stranger, a woman names Rowan, added some mystery but led to the healing of this family. It was a haunting tale and is a reminder of how fragile our ecosystem is. The book slowly built in mystery and the trauma that each family member was dealing with was portrayed with such care. Really loved this story. Thank you to the author and Flatiron Books for a copy of this book to review.
Christina
That Last Carolina Summer by Karen White
This was a good summer read with interesting characters and a good plot. I thought it was going to be a cozy romance novel, but it was intriguing and kept my interest with the mystery storyline and family drama. It was a quick read and worth picking up this summer!
Christina
Nantucket Summer House by Pamela Kelley
Was a very quick read and enjoyable to go back to the Plum Cove Inn and see what Lisa and her family were up to!
Christina
Maggie, or a Man and Woman Walk Into a Bar by Katie Yee
This was a story about a woman who thinks she is happily married finding out unexpectedly that her husband had an affair and is leaving her. She then has to navigate her life as a single parent with primary responsibility for her children as well as learning she has cancer.
Christina
The Incredible Kindness of Paper by Evelyn Skye
This was a sweet, uplifting love story of two teenagers who were separated and then reunited after 17 years apart. The events that bring them together invoke paper origami roses that Chloe makes to bring joy and friendship to the people in NYC. The story intertwines the lives of a number of people that would have never met if it was not for the roses made of paper.
Christina
To the Moon and Back by Eliana Ramage
This was a great read that explores the childhood and adult life of a Native American woman who is obsessed with becoming the first Native American astronaut. The book deals with her relationship with her mother and sister as well as three romantic interests that she has had throughout her life. The book also looks at the life of Della, who meets Steph in college. She is also the daughter of a Native American and a non-native American mother who she never meets. The characters are rich and the storyline is sad at times, but it is a great story.
Christina
High Season by Katie Bishop
This was a good mystery that involves a woman who was convicted of killing a 17-year-old girl, 29 years ago when she was the same age. The story examines the relationships of the family of Tamara, who was murdered in her posh mansion in the south of France at the family as well as the repercussions of the woman who was convicted and spent 10 years in prison for that crime. A podcaster wants to look into the crime as Josie has claimed she was innocent of the crime.
Christina
Hot Desk by Laura Dickerman
I enjoyed this book which was about two editors in a publishing house who are forced to share a desk due to space consolidation. There is also a very compelling story of Rebecca’s mother who, when she was younger, wanted to become a writer and takes an internship with a literary publication.
Debbie
The Good Liar by Denise Mina
Denise Mina writes an interesting novel based on the scientific reading of blood spatters at a murder scene, but too much detail and rambling into other areas. Dr. Claudia O’Sheil explains blood spatters and suggests a possible killer. Claudia’s evidence convicts and locks up murderers, but is this evidence 100% accurate? A wealthy older man and his current love interest are brutally murdered, and his son falls victim to Claudia’s program. Viscount William Stewart heads to jail, this poor soul even confesses to the two murders, but the police have no evidence. This game of cat and mouse begins with a list of suspects and clues to the murder. Claudia must decide if she was wrong and what she must do now. Easy to read.
Debbie
The Sunflower House by Adriana Allegri
THE SUNFLOWER HOUSE details the horrors of Hitler’s Germany. The story jumps back and forth between Germany in 1939 until 1943, and New Jersey in 2006. So many unanswered questions concerning this chapter in Germany for me. What happened to the “Hitler” babies after the war? Did these adopted babies thrive? How many? And how many were killed due to imperfections? The story revolves around Lebensborn program of creating the “perfect” race. Allina Strauss watches in horror as her aunt and thousands of other individuals fall victim to the Nazis. Allina escapes only to be brutally raped and forced to work in Hochland House, a German birthing clinic. Adriana Allegri writes an emotional story of a terrible time.
Francisca
Six Cats a Slayin' by Miranda James
Book # 10 in the Cats in the Stacks series of cozy mysteries, featuring Charlie Harris, librarian, and his Maine Coone cat, Diesel. The main mystery is the death of neighbor, Gerry Albritton. But two subplots take up as much time (or more). I like Charlie as a central character, and he has a nice retinue of friends, relatives, colleagues who help him out with life and with his investigations.
Ruthanne
Last Call at the Savoy by Brisa Carleton
I enjoyed the writing style of this author, but the story itself was just okay. I expected more but still worth a read. Ihope the author writes another book. I think the potential is there.
Luella
The Night She Disappeared by Lisa Jewell
An unusual mystery that is hard to put down. An unexpected ending.
Rose
For the Love of Friends by Sara Goodman Confino
Sara Goodman Confino's books are a joy to read. I laughed several times in this novel where, Lily, 32, bemoans being a bridesmaid in 5 weddings, all within weeks of each other. When the other bridesmaids, and sometimes the brides, become unbearable in their demands and attitude, Lily writes an anonymous blog about all of it. It is quite a funny take on the whole wedding craziness, especially what it has become in recent years. Then there is the unknown of her sleeping with someone that she doesn't recall. When she becomes friends with one of the groomsmen in her friend's wedding party, she blows it all with a confession. So enjoyable and fun!
Terry
The Killing Stones by Ann Cleeves
Good mystery, interesting story with well developed characters.
Debbie
People Like Us by Jason Mott
A waste of my time, a rambling book. The narrator and main character, Soot, jumps from one life experience to another catastrophe and the journey uncovers pure ennui. Soot must talk his way out of a man trying to kill him, attempt to reconcile his ex-wife, and enjoy a luxury jaunt to Europe. Soot constantly reminds the reader of the N-word (National Book Award) that he has won. The story centers on Soot’s love of himself regardless of what other people think. So glad that the book ends quickly and a better book to read awaits.
Pam
Onyx Storm by Rebecca Yarros
Fast-paced romance, war, and mystery combined into one book.
Lucy
Theo of Golden by Allen Levi
A heartwarming story of an elder man gifting portraits to their rightful owners. We not only learn more about the older man, Theo, but about the friendships and lives of the recipients. A wonderful book with characters I want to meet.
Dorothy
The Correspondent by Virginia Evans
I loved the author's use of letters to tell the story of the main 70-ish female character to her family, boyfriend and lifelong friend. Great for book club.
Carol
The Heart's Invisible Furies by John Boyne
This is the story of Cyril Avery from his birth until he’s in his 70s, and it’s a personal story and a view of a repressive and evolving Ireland. It is humorous it is tragic, the protagonist who was constantly wrestling with shame and desire and love. He delivers a masterpiece that both is an indictment to a type of life and also forgives this type of life. Each chapter leaps ahead by seven years creating a rhythm. It’s about fragility of life and there are moments of uncertainty, crashing in after long stretches of quiet struggle. It’s a wonderful story, extraordinarily emotional. It captures a life and all its contradictions all its failures and its great moments. It’s about resilience being kinder to ourselves.
Carol
A Fire Endless by Rebecca Ross
This is the second book in a trilogy. The first book is THE RIVER ENCHANTED, which was absolutely excellent. This story is entrenched in Scottish folk magic, and the island is split in two by an ages old feud between the Timberland’s and Breccans. We have two lovers, Jack and Adaira, who are working to solve a plague that is causing a mysterious disease in its people, and the spirits of the island are also sick. This is a very good story I highly recommend it. This is a great relationship. The romance is terrific. The drama is epic and it’s a mix of fantasy and romance, and it was a good ending to the series.
Beth
Heart Life Music by Kenny Chesney with Holly Gleason
I enjoyed this light-hearted narrative by Kenny Chesney that explores his east-Tennessee roots and his journey to Nashville, his successes and his failures. Chesney is endearing and warm in his language. His stories detail the evolution of his songs, and I could not help but think of the stories the next time I heard the songs.
Pamela
The Award by Matthew Pearl
Well written with a great plot.
Pattie
A Guardian and a Thief by Megha Majumdar
Couldn’t put it down!
Michael
We Did OK, Kid: A Memoir by Sir Anthony Hopkins
I enjoy a good memoir! Anthony Hopkins has lived an interesting life. I would have loved it if the book was a little bit longer and he went more in depth into his many projects. He has had a very successful career so a lot got glossed over, but his insight was very interesting to me. Also, the end was very odd. A bunch of poetry that didn't seem to have anything to do with anything. I didn't dislike it. I just found it to be a bit of a head-scratcher and a weird way to end the book. But, overall, great read!
Virginia
Theo of Golden by Allen Levi
A story about a mysterious newcomer, Theo, to the town of Golden and his quest to buy portraits of townspeople painted by a local artist. He plans on gifting these portraits to them. As the story unfolds, we learn about their lives through the interactions they have with Theo. Beautifully written. This is a debut novel for this author and I look forward to reading more from him.
Robin
Fawning, Fawning, Fawning by Dr. Ingrid Clayton
Most people know about flight, freeze, fight but not fawning. I learned why I people please and how to heal reading this book.
Mindy
The Coworker by Freida McFadden
If you’re a fan of Freida McFadden books, this is a good one. She always has twists and turns to keep you guessing until the end.
Sharon
Gone Before Goodbye by Reese Witherspoon and Harlan Coben
Long build up.
Cheryl
Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt
Marcellus, our lead character, is an octopus with three hearts and great affection for Tova Sullivan, the cleaning lady at his aquarium in Washington State. Marcellus ‘sees’ the big picture and risks his life to bring Tiva and Cameron to the realization that they are family. I was a bit weepy by the end of the book. I also was thrilled to find a Dala horse to bring with me to our book club discussion later this month.
Mindy
Born a Crime by Trevor Noah
I listened to the audiobook, narrated by Trevor. Such an interesting account of his early life and life in South Africa as a “colored” person. He’s a wonderful storyteller and it gives you a snapshot of what it was like post-apartheid.
Sheree
The Heir Apparent by Rebecca Armitage
Loved the book. I felt like I was behind the scenes looking back in. The author had a way of drawing you right into the story. Perfect book to read after knee surgery!!
Muriel
Christmas with the Queen by Hazel Gaynor and Heather Webb
This is a fictionalized view into the life of Queen Elizabeth as she ascends to the throne after her father’s death and begins her yearly Christmas Day radio message in 1952. The book gives a more intimate, personal glimpse of the Queen thought to be too formal and detached from the lives of her subjects. In addition, the authors have created a story centering around characters Oliver Carter and Jack Devereau. Olive, a single mother and aspiring writer for the BBC, and Jack, a recently widowed chef working in the Royal kitchen, were friends when young and could have been romantic partners. When they meet again, misunderstandings keep getting in the way. Jack and Olive’s interactions with the Royals and their own story are interesting.
Suzanne
The Tin Men by Nelson and Alex DeMille
I found the concept of this book intriguing and the idea that this could really happen is frightening.
Melissa
The Bangalore Detectives Club by Harini Nagendra
Fun and engaging, if a bit predictable.
Sharon
Filthy Rich: The Shocking True Story of Jeffrey Epstein by James Patterson and John Connolly with Tim Malloy
Rating 3.5 stars. Read it because it was written in 2017 and wanted to see what was known about Epstein.
Sharon
Nobody's Girl: A Memoir of Surviving Abuse and Fighting for Justice by Virginia Roberts Giuffre
Such an amazing story and all the trials and tribulations Virginia went through at the hands of Epstein and Maxwell. Those two should burn in hell as well as everyone who covered for them.
Sharon
The Dressmaker of Khair Khana: Five Sisters, One Remarkable Family, and the Woman Who Risked Everything to Keep Them Safe by Gayle Tzemach Lemmon
The story of Kamila Sidiqi, a young woman living under the Taliban regime in Afghanistan, who is starting a business with the women of her village sewing clothes.
Sharon
Don't Look Now by Mary Burton
Story of a female detective who losing her eyesight when trying to find the serial killer of young blonde women who looked like her. Keeps you seating on the edge of your seat.
Melissa
The Names by Florence Knapp
I really liked the book. Very creative plot.
Linda
I Was Anastasia by Ariel Lawhon
The account of the assassination of the Romanov family and the hopeful, decades-long legend of the surviving daughter Anastasia is told alternatively from the first-person narrative of the young Anastasia and the third-person narrative of Anna Anderson, who claimed to be the daughter of the murdered Tsar. I listened on audio, which was read by two different narrators. I've read a lot of dual timeline books, so this wasn't a problem for me, but it did jump around a lot so it was hard to keep the timeline straight at times. I enjoyed the parts about the young Anastasia and her family more, although it was sadder and more difficult to listen to at times. Another sad and tragic event in history that I knew very little about.
Linda
The Fountains of Silence by Ruta Sepetys
Another excellent book by Ruta Sepetys! A story about things that took place post-WWII that I knew nothing about, this one in Spain. Loved the characters and the plot twists, and the very satisfying ending.
Linda
The Little Liar by Mitch Albom
I rarely give 5 stars but I honestly couldn't think of a single reason to drop this lower. Loved the characters and their storylines, and how the author kept them connected over the course of decades. I also appreciated learning about the effects of the Holocaust on Jews living in Greece, which I don't recall ever reading about. I've seen comments about the story being "contrived", far-fetched, or not believable. It's fiction, so the whole story is made-up, and the author has liberty to write the story the way he wants. I loved it.
Wendy
The Correspondent by Virginia Evans
One of the best I read in 2025. Just a great story.
laura
May the Wolf Die by Elizabeth Heider
Interesting story taking place in Italy. Niki finds herself involved in solving two deaths of American naval personnel.
Lee
One of Us by Dan Chaon
Interesting story set in a turn-of-the century carnival. Trails off at the end.
Jeanne
Imposter by L. J. Ross
Intriguing plot that follows the work of a criminal profiler.
Mimi
The Lost Story of Eva Fuentes by Chanel Cleeton
I’ve always been fascinated by Cuba and the relationship with the U. S. This book introduced me to a part of our history that I had no idea had happened. Teachers from Cuba came to Boston in the summer of 1900 to attend a special program at Harvard. It also reminds you how important a book can be.
Beth
The Black Wolf by Louise Penny
The wonderful residents of Three Pines face incredibly current threats. I finished the book this weekend (January 4th), wondering who will be our Gamache.
Cheryl
Hamnet by Maggie O'Farrell
A Shakespearean tale about Shakespeare.
Wanda
Will to Murder by Gail Feichtinger
This book of true crime is the best overall book I’ve read that I can recall. Great writing, research and in-depth of the Glensheen killings. Was not easy to put down and a real page-turner. Such a shame that an adopted daughter could have such greed. Fascinating!
Beverly
Skylark by Paula McLain
Very compelling historical fiction, but the dual timeline bothered me more than it usually does. I very much enjoyed the female characters and learned some interesting things about dye plants and the process used. Also about the tunnels under Paris! Who knew?
Julie
The Art Spy by Michelle Young
Fascinating look at the work of Rose Valland, who as an art lover/curator, saved thousands of pieces of art during the looting of Paris during WWII.
Jan
My Dark Vanessa by Kate Elizabeth Russell
Dark but very interesting story.
Belva
Wreck Your Heart by Lori Rader-Day
3.5 stars rounded up. WRECK YOUR HEART is an enjoyable mystery with a quirky wanna-be country singer as the main character. Turns out she has a lot of emotional scars and depth to her. While the plot may be a bit far-fetched, the characters are well developed and the story well paced. I would recommend this one to music lovers and cozy mystery fans.
Jana
The Heir Apparent by Rebecca Armitage
Loved, loved this book from a new author to me.
Nina
The Heir Apparent by Rebecca Armitage
To me, this story closely parallels the lives of Queen Elizabeth and her family! Lots of intrigue and sub themes are included.
Jan
Theo of Golden by Allen Levi
If you enjoyed THE CORRESPONDENT, Theo of Golden is your next book. Self-published author. A feel good, heartwarming story with complex twists.
Elizabeth
Buckeye by Patrick Ryan
This book gathers momentum slowly, drawing the reader into the characters' lives. I will definitely recommend it to my book club.
Jeanne
The Proving Ground by Michael Connelly
THE PROVING GROUND by Michael Connelly is a well-written legal thriller with very good research that focuses on the topic of artificial intelligence and how it affects children. Michael Haller is at his best in the courtroom in this entertaining, informative storyline. At the beginning I wasn’t sure if I was going to like reading it. I could not have been more wrong because the more I read, the more drawn in I was until I didn’t want to put the book down for a second. I read it cover to cover and recommend reading it. The ending had me on the edge of my seat with anticipation of how it would end. I think this is one of the author’s best books.
LisaMarie
The Lies They Told by Ellen Marie Wiseman
This book really made you think of all the people that came over here to try to get a better life for their families. I know my grandma and grandpa did. What brave people and what they had to endure. To think that you could just have your whole life ripped apart from you and your children, and most of all what horror for women to have to be sterilized for no reason whatsoever. It’s really sad and heartwrenching. I did thoroughly enjoy this book only for the fact that it brings to light how you should really appreciate everything in your life, and those who came before us to fight for us to have a better life.
Gail
Gone Before Goodbye by Harlan Coben and Reese Witherspoon
A fast-moving, twisty plot involving a well-known plastic surgeon and a Russian oligarch with other shady characters thrown in. Not to be missed!
Linda
A Christmas Witness by Charles Todd
A fun, quick read with an interesting twist.
Rebecca
Come Fly the World by Julia Cooke
Very informative and educational. I listened to the audio version, which was done very well; it like listening to old stories. Angering and also admirable. We've come a long way, but still have a long way to go.
Luella
Shattered Dreams by Irene Spencer
A true story of a polygamous wife and family. Hard to imagine their beliefs.
Joanne
Christmas with the Queen by Hazel Gaynor and Heather Webb
A lovely story about second chances and forgiveness.
Denise
Midnight at the Blackbird Cafe by Heather Webber
An easy read.
Ivy
Madness: Race and Insanity in a Jim Crow Asylum by Antonia Hylton
The story of Crownsville State Hospital is one that will stay with me forever. The treatment of patients, many of whom were taken off the streets of Baltimore in the 40s, 50s and 60s merely because they may have been homeless, or deemed dangerous to themselves or others, were treated in the most horrific ways and conditions. This story left me saddened and wondering about the lives taken and destroyed under the guise of medical treatment.
Cesar
Culture Shock by César R. Frausto
This book totally changed my perspective on life in general and helped me understand such a controversial issue that is seen (and has been seen for so many years) in regards to immigration in the United States and how it impacts lives in a detailed description. I never expected a read to be so emotionally impacting.
Elizabeth
Wildwood by Amy Pease
Shaky Lake, Sherman County, Wisconsin, and Sheriff Marge and her deputy officer Eli welcome us back for another crime investigation. For a small town of one thousand, there are always brutal crimes happening. This time they are investigating a missing undercover agent, Trinity, but it doesn’t look good from the bloody scene in her trailer. Readers who enjoy thrillers, surprises, great characters, and great descriptions will enjoy WILDWOOD. It is a bit of a slow start, but you will get invested in the story and the characters, and enjoy how it all cleverly turns out.
Anna
The Stolen Queen by Fiona Davis
Thrilling historical fiction, set between the NY and Cairo. Then visit the Met Museum and do the scavenger hunt, leading to art pieces referenced in the book.
Clare
Atmosphere by Taylor Jenkins Reid
Growing up in the 70s, I was fascinated by the space program. Taylor Jenkins Reid brought it all back to me and more.
Abby
The Elements by John Boyne
A great book to start off the New Year. John Boyne has four interconnected stories in one book that he somehow brings together seamlessly. Parts of this book are not for the faint of heart, but it is a well-plotted story and you will want to keep turning the pages. No spoilers here, but a strong recommendation.
Rosemarie
Ladies in Waiting: Jane Austen's Unsung Characters by Adriana Trgiani, Sarah McLean, Eloisa Jones, Elinor Lipman and 10 more
Witty, fun reimagining of a few minor characters in Jane Austen's novels by nine contemporary authors who have been influenced by their love and admiration of Austen and who chose a character each felt a special affinity for. These women are now given a reimagined starring role! Perfect end read for 250th celebration of Jane Austen's birthday!
Maureen
Beyond That, the Sea by Laura Spence-Ash
Told in epistolary style, this beautifully-written novel follows the lives of a British girl whose mother sends her to the U. S. during the London "Blitz" and the American family she is placed with. Over a period of several years, the author shapes and develops the characters through their correspondence with each other during and after WWII. I was totally engaged in the intertwined relationships on both sides of the Atlantic as lives and circumstances became altered in the post-war years. In this debut novel, unpredictable events create a bond between the families that transcends time and distance. Masterfully crafted and a joy to read, the ending came much too soon and left me wanting more from this gifted storyteller.
Joanne
The Lion Women of Tehran by Marjan Kamali
Truly enjoyed this book. Lifelong friendships, hardships, personal struggles - just a few of the subjects included in this well-written book.
Minna
The Red House by Mary Morris
Beautifully-written book that moves between Italy in 1943 and today, as well as New Jersey in 1972.
Judith
James by Percival Everett
Interesting characters in the story.
Dianne
Peggy by Rebecca Godfrey
This is an intriguing look at Peggy Guggenheim's life in the first half of the twentieth century. Unfortunately, the last third of the book was completed after the author died and it is not as entertaining as the first two thirds.
Lori
The Quiet Game by Greg Isles
The characters in this page-turner stay with you and you find yourself anxiously reading to find out what happens next. This is the second book I have read in the Penn Cage series, and I have the third one on my “TBR” list.
Pam
Wreck by Catherine Newman
Family matters and drama.
Sean
Broken Prey by John Sandford
After all these novels in this series, John Sandford still impresses. This might have been my favorite Prey novel. The book and series does such a good job as a police procedural. Here, Lucas Davenport and team deal with a heinous antagonist or two that keeps him guessing. It's great to see how his mind works trying to work out the situation. There were a handful of red herrings that actually make sense, especially in hindsight. The ending was brutal and satisfying. The book had me interested in getting back to it any time I wasn't reading. Overall, an incredibly entertaining and violent police thriller.
Rose
A Separate Peace by John Knowles
A coming-of-age story set at a boarding school during WWII. The narrator, Gene, returns to the school years later and reflects on the events of his time there, and his friendship with Phineas, his charismatic roommate. Phineas (Finny) was an elite athlete, fun-loving, and a risk taker. He influences Gene, an intellectual, to loosen up and do things he wouldn't normally do. But, this summer where they are together, an event happens to change their lives. Gene feels guilty, Phineas doesn't want to believe it, but others say it is true - and that changes everything. Sad story of jealousy, insecurity, and impulsive moves.
Rose
Good Grief by Sara Goodman Confino
Barbara is grieving the loss of her husband, Henry. Her mother has lived with her and her children for 2 years, but Barbara is now ready to be on her own. Yet, she isn't prepared for her mother-in-law, Ruth, to move in! Ruth disrupts Barbara's life, her home, and tries to set Barbara up with various men. Barbara is also trying to be a matchmaker for Ruth, to get her out of the house! The book is endearing and shows how these two women learn to live together and respect each other. A sweet novel with a nice message.
Rose
The Mad Wife by Meagan Church
Set in the 1950s, Lulu does whatever it takes to be the perfect wife for her husband Henry. She loves being mom to her son Wesley. She spends her day cooking and cleaning and prepping for dinner parties for her husband as he tries for a new position. She watches the house across the street, and when a family moves in, she becomes even more involved in watching their lives. When she goes into labor, she names her daughter Esther, but becomes increasingly paranoid. She believes she is going to get a lobotomy, similar to what happened to (she believes) her neighbor. She feels guilt over what happened to her brother, and she doesn't know how to cope. Terrifying in part, concerning and tense, this is another good novel from Church.
Richard N B
The Kennedy Detail by Gerald Blaine with Lisa McCubbin
Subtitle: JFK’s Secret Service Agents Break Their Silence. This book was written some fifty years after the events of Nov 22, 1963. Blaine was one of the agents assigned to the Kennedy Detail, protecting the president, the vice president, their wives and children. He and the other agents on the detail had never spoken about the events in Dallas to one another, nor really to anyone (other than testimony they gave to investigators). But none of them had forgotten. I found this very interesting.
Linda
The Shop on Hidden Lane by Jayne Ann Krentz
Good paranormal romance.
Elizabeth
Not Quite Dead Yet by Holly Jackson
Good but could have been better.
Donna
Small Bomb at Dimperley by Lissa Evans
SMALL BOMB AT DIMPERLEY by Lissa Evans was a joyous romp through the English countryside. Ms. Evans has penned a heartwarming, witty historical novel that is both funny and poignant. It was such a pleasure to get to know all the quirky, eccentric characters. I adored this delightful read.
Lisa
The Story She Left Behind by Patti Callahan Henry
This story was heartfelt and well-developed. The English countryside was beautifully described and even included the famed author Beatrix Potter, who lived nearby. There was just enough tension to keep me turning the pages and feeling invested in the charming characters. A very enjoyable read about an interesting time in British history.
Rose
A Marriage at Sea: A True Story of Love, Obsession, and Shipwreck by Sophie Elmhirst
Maralyn and Maurice are a strange pair, and he is shocked when she agrees to marry him. He is an introvert, she is outgoing. He loves to sail, and after getting her out on the water, they decide to sell their home and sail halfway around the world from England to New Zealand. They meticulously pack for their voyage, but without a radio per Maurice's wishes. One day, while in the Pacific Ocean, they realize a whale has hit their ship. They grab what they can, and move onto the dinghy, watching the ship sink. They then spend nearly 4 months floating in the ocean with little provisions, while ships pass them by. Finally rescued, they have to deal with newfound fame. Without Maralyn's resourcefulness, they would have likely died.
Rose
Beyond Reasonable Doubt by Robert Dugoni
The second book in the Keera Duggan series finds Keera defending a frenemy from her childhood. Jenna was already found not guilty a few years earlier in the killing of her biotech company's chief scientist, defended by Patsy, Keera's dad. Keera has never trusted Jenna and doesn't know if she can believe that Keera didn't kill her business partner and lover. Keera doesn't even believe she loved the man that was killed. As Keera investigates and puts on her defense, she gives Jenna an ultimatum. Interesting and complex case. Reminded me a bit of the tech controversy around Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos. (without the murder!)
Rose
A Novel Christmas by Charity Shane'
A quick Christmas read. An author isn't bringing in the top 10 best sellers that her publisher wants, so the publisher assigns her to write a holiday novel for the following season. Saira heads to Santa Claus, Indiana to research holiday traditions for her next romance novel. She rents a place from a former NFL player, Dorian, who is a very handsome widower. His heart is still grieving, but there is an attraction between the two. Lots of graphic scenes, I don't know why they fell in love except for the attraction between them. I didn't get the relationship.
Candice
What Have You Done? by Shari Lapena
This story starts off interesting, but slowly gets repetitive. A teenage girl in a small town is found murdered and the suspects are her boyfriend, a creepy gym teacher, and a shady customer at the store where she worked. The chapters keep going around in circles about things that happened to this girl over and over. The men are awful. The ending is also abrupt. The author does not really describe her characters much. The small town setting was well described. Not the best read.
