The Man Nobody Killed: Life, Death, and Art in Michael Stewart's New York
Review
The Man Nobody Killed: Life, Death, and Art in Michael Stewart's New York
In 1983, Michael Stewart was just another kid who came to New York City to pursue a dream. He was an artist, a deejay and a model, enjoying the downtown club scene and working hard at his jobs.
The 25-year-old wanted to make a name for himself --- and tragically he did just that by way of a brutal beating by New York City Transit Authority police after being caught tagging a subway wall at 14th Street. (Tagging is the name given to the spraying of an artist’s graffiti “tag” on a piece of public property.) The news was a blast heard around the world and cemented the young man’s name in the annals of the ’80s, along with the Central Park Five and the Preppy Killer.
Edgar Award-winning author Elon Green gives a complete rundown on Stewart, his untimely death, and the lasting consequences of that barbaric incident in his latest book, THE MAN NOBODY KILLED.
"Green is a good writer who brings the backdrop of the crazy ’80s into full 4K view. He demonstrates that Stewart deserved so much more than what he received, and the stretch of justice from that night to today has not grown as much as it should have."
Forty years after the murder, the case still holds many of the worst traits of the United States in the Go-Go decade, where money and violence took precedence over the hippie dream that died with the ’70s. The AIDS crisis, the racism exhibited through police activities, and the innocence of the young artists who thought that New York City would welcome them with open arms are all woven into this disturbing and well-paced story. Green has fashioned a thriller out of the incident and its outcome (and left out some of the sensitivity that I personally hoped would be an important part of the narrative). It is a wicked take on a wicked act that brings back some of the more intensive concerns about safety in this oppressive, gun-addled society.
The specifics of the story are not spared. Witnesses saw officers beat this defenseless young man with billy clubs, choke him with a nightstick, and dump him at Bellevue Hospital without a heartbeat. The book should’ve been marked with a trigger warning given US history and the continued mountain of bodies of men such as Stewart to whom civil rights movements like Black Lives Matter have been dedicated year after year. However, Green does not skimp on his personal story, so he becomes a brother, a son and a friend to everyone who reads the book.
And then there is the parade of artists and singers, including Madonna, Keith Haring, Spike Lee and Jean-Michel Basquiat, who joined journalists like Jimmy Breslin, Murray Kempton and WNBC's Gabe Pressman to raise awareness of the killing and ask constant questions about the case, especially as the police suffered no real consequences. Stewart’s family called for justice, using the platform the stars provided, and several investigations were launched into his wrongful death.
Green is a good writer who brings the backdrop of the crazy ’80s into full 4K view. He demonstrates that Stewart deserved so much more than what he received, and the stretch of justice from that night to today has not grown as much as it should have.
If only THE MAN NOBODY KILLED could be considered a fable, a final story about how the old oppressive powers of greedy authorities were taken to task and protections created for vulnerable young people. However, knowing that this brutality could have happened just the other day hopefully will help everyone work harder for police watchdogging.
Reviewed by Jana Siciliano on March 21, 2025
The Man Nobody Killed: Life, Death, and Art in Michael Stewart's New York
- Publication Date: March 11, 2025
- Genres: Nonfiction, True Crime
- Hardcover: 288 pages
- Publisher: Celadon Books
- ISBN-10: 1250898226
- ISBN-13: 9781250898227