Postmortem: What Survives the John Wayne Gacy Murders
Review
Postmortem: What Survives the John Wayne Gacy Murders
The dedication at the beginning of POSTMORTEM reads: “For all the boys.” On the next page, Courtney Lund O’Neil quotes the Simple Minds song “Don’t You (Forget About Me)” and includes the interesting tidbit that the high school used for the movie The Breakfast Club was in Des Plaines, Illinois --- the same town where serial killer John Wayne Gacy lived.
How ironic that a film about teen angst and arrested youth development should take place in the same area where so many young lives ended at the hands of one of the nation’s most notorious serial killers. What makes this book stand out is that O’Neil happens to be the daughter of the young woman who was mainly responsible for pointing the police in Gacy’s direction, which resulted in his prosecution and death by lethal injection.
"The entire court case is covered in a way that will place you directly there, and O’Neil pens a fascinating book that is as hard to look away from as a car crash on the highway."
The narrative is also unique, told in a style reminiscent of great historical fiction, in which the events and characters are at times depicted as if they are in a fictional work. Jumping back and forth in time, it puts us right in the mind of Kim Byers, who was a friend and co-worker of Rob Piest, the teenager who ended up being Gacy’s final victim. As O’Neil, who also writes herself into the story, steps on the grounds where Gacy’s house once stood, it literally will send chills up your spine. The fact that dozens of bodies of young men were found there leaves a horrifying vision of what true evil is --- an evil that is set amidst the once-innocent suburbs of Des Plaines.
The utmost credibility is given to all the passages involving Kim as blurbs from her personal journals are included. One day, at the pharmacy where Kim and Rob worked, Kim witnessed Rob stepping outside to speak with the contractor who had been doing work at the store. He was never seen again. However, it was more than just Kim’s eyewitness testimony that put the police on to Gacy. It was a cold day, and Kim had taken Rob’s parka to wear at work. Not only was that very same coat discovered at Gacy’s house by police, a piece of paper was also found there --- the receipt for Kim’s photos that she inadvertently had slipped into the pocket.
POSTMORTEM is told from the point of view of the victims and those who were directly impacted by Gacy’s evil, rather than from the killer’s perspective, which also makes for a different kind of true crime read. The entire court case is covered in a way that will place you directly there, and O’Neil pens a fascinating book that is as hard to look away from as a car crash on the highway. It is not to be missed, and true crime fans will be rewarded in spades by a story that leaves the reader content in the fact that justice was served.
Reviewed by Ray Palen on January 11, 2025
Postmortem: What Survives the John Wayne Gacy Murders
- Publication Date: December 24, 2024
- Genres: Memoir, Nonfiction, True Crime
- Hardcover: 272 pages
- Publisher: Citadel
- ISBN-10: 0806542993
- ISBN-13: 9780806542997