Skip to main content

Peregrine Hill

Review

Peregrine Hill

The daughter of a poor Count and an American mother, 37-year-old widow Isabelle Bishop knows how to cut her own path through the cutthroat galas and cocktail parties of New York City’s Gilded Age. But after losing her husband and three of her children in the Morrigan shipwreck, the formerly comfortable --- at times even wealthy --- woman has found herself in dire straits. Though she married for love and adored her late husband, his bad business decisions cost her and her surviving daughter, 18-year-old Mariah, everything: their homes in Boston and Maine, their entire inheritance, and even their family keepsakes. 

Isabelle is now ensconced in Hoboken, New Jersey, with her daughter and elderly mother, and she has been forced to take stock of her assets. Chief among them is her body, which is still youthful and taut. Despite her attempts to seduce uber-wealthy John Whitten, himself a widower two times over at 63, he sees greater value in Mariah with what she can offer him: his first heir. For many mothers, his lecherous gaze and the jarring age gap would be enough to say no, but the early 20th century provides little support or protection for single women. Besides, Whitten has something on Mariah that can never be made public.

Lost in the throes of her grief at losing her beloved father and favorite sibling, Mariah --- angelically beautiful and equally as kind --- suffered a lapse in judgment the previous summer courtesy of Jay Hopkins, a dashing lothario with an artist’s passion. Practical to a fault, Isabelle made no fuss about hiding away her daughter’s condition and finding a family to adopt her only grandchild. But now Mariah’s future is also at risk. Even though the times are just beginning to change, with suffragists holding court on every corner, no man would look twice at Mariah if he knew she was impure. But Whitten, desperate for an heir and boasting what he claims is a progressive perspective, sees in Mariah only opportunity.

"PEREGRINE HILL reads not like historical fiction, but history itself. Readers of Fiona Davis will devour this standout novel and applaud its championing of headstrong women and their boundless resilience."

So it is that Mariah is wed to Whitten, whose frequent promises that he knows “how to please a woman” fall on the deaf ears of his teenage bride. Mariah is gobsmacked by Isabelle's callousness and vows never to speak to her again. Nevertheless, Whitten sets Isabelle and her mother up in a lavish estate, with all their needs delivered at no cost. Mariah, meanwhile, is forced to move to Peregrine Hill, Whitten’s gaudy, castle-like manor. But as she ascends to the upper echelons of society, the cast of characters --- and their myriad motives --- expands rapidly.

Mariah soon finds a kindred spirit in her lady's maid, Hetty, a spirited, brazen young woman with a gift for editing. And she delights in the frequent visits of Lavinia Van Wye, a widow who is Whitten’s occasional lover. But despite these bright spots, Peregrine Hill is more like a prison than a home. Every night she is forced to bed Whitten, and every day she is trailed by his creepy henchman, Mr. Smythe, who is devoid of personality but rife with evil. Fortunately, the staff takes an immediate liking to Mariah, who treats everyone from the glamorous women she meets at galas to the kitchen staff and stable boys with the same kindness and generosity. But even they cannot balance out the truth: Mariah is the prize in a devil’s bargain, and it was her own mother who put her there.

As Mariah adapts to life in Gilded Age New York, she and Hetty form a close bond grounded in their shared love of books, with Mariah the hopeful writer and Hetty the sharp editor. Slowly, the two begin to carve out a small semblance of freedom by producing stories for a magazine. But the metaphors of teenage girls can often hew a bit too close to the truth. With all eyes on the fabulously wealthy Whitten and his gorgeous teenage bride, tongues begin to wag, and not just about the anonymous writer penning stories of greedy men and exploited women. You see, the New York of this era is glamorous, scented by cigar smoke and dripping in champagne. But beneath the glitz and gold lie a toxic underbelly, a vicious rumor mill and the dangerous desires of men. 

Nina de Gramont structures PEREGRINE HILL almost like a play, with each set --- from New York’s Fifth Avenue to the Hamptons to the homes of royals in London --- erecting itself to be populated by deeply compelling characters, each of whom harbors their own motivations, dreams and alliances, all revealed in whip-smart, snappy dialogue. As mother and daughter, Isabelle and Mariah provide the beating heart of the novel: two women who are in an impossible situation yet still find a way to survive, even when that survival looks like complacency. The juxtaposition of these horrific circumstances and the suffragist movement creates a glorious tension that captures the potential of the early 20th century.

Nearly everyone from Hetty to Jay to Isabelle has a secret romance and risks losing everything if their secrets are revealed. Each of these dynamics unfolds against a backdrop of glittering cocktail parties, corseted dresses and the windswept beaches of the East Coast, creating a narrative that is full of all the upstairs-downstairs tension of “Downton Abbey” and the satiric wit of Edith Wharton, as seen through the romantic eyes of the Brontë sisters. 

This historic tour de force is peppered with desperate and resilient women, devious and vulgar men, and a few questionable deaths and surprising pregnancies. The end result is dishy and wildly fun, but grounded in meticulous details. De Gramont brings to life everything from the shipwreck that steals Isabelle’s family to Mariah’s first time riding in a car, and even the early 20th-century publishing scene (with one editor confidently remarking, “The pressure of publishing is beyond what a woman can bear”).

Set against the backdrop of Gilded Age New York, populated by raw, intense characters, and driven by the impossible choices women have long been forced to make, PEREGRINE HILL reads not like historical fiction, but history itself. Readers of Fiona Davis will devour this standout novel and applaud its championing of headstrong women and their boundless resilience.

Reviewed by Rebecca Munro on November 13, 2026

Peregrine Hill
by Nina de Gramont