Fair Ones: A Double Novel
Review
Fair Ones: A Double Novel
Lydia Millet’s FAIR ONES is described as a “double novel,” but it is hard to imagine one half of this book without the other. Perhaps that is the point, actually. The two halves, two perspectives on the same loss but different responses to it, need each other for sense and clarity, for stability and meaning, even though they are, technically, distinct.
When Claire is shot and killed at a New York City bus stop in what at first seems to be a random act of violence, her two best friends, Mara and Jen, are stunned and then devastated. Readers move with Mara through the first year of grief in the section titled “Fair” as she and Jen manage immediate arrangements and memorials, as well as their own anger and sorrow.
Mara, though she often shares Jen’s rage, is quieter and calmer, and is less prone to lash out. She is competent in the weeks following Claire’s death but struggling to process her own feelings. She befriends a memoirist who was in a book club with Claire, and his insight and strength offer her what Jen cannot.
"FAIR ONES is a dialogue-driven novel, but there is a lot of action that takes place and so much emotional depth and development as well. Millet is masterful in handling it all."
As the weeks and months go by, Mara and Jen begin to piece together details of Claire’s death and uncover evidence that they bring to the police. All the while, Mara reckons with concerns about her aging mother and her own middle age, and she enters into a relationship with the father of a student she tutors.
At the start of the first year after Claire’s death, Jen is struggling in her own way. The book's second half, “Ones,” is told from her first-person perspective. She is sober now, having disappeared to a Jain community after hitting rock bottom and keeping some shameful secrets from both Mara and her partner, Richard. And now her career is taking her in some new and exciting directions. But the loss of Claire is still raw and painful and very much in the foreground of Jen’s life. Jen’s relationship with Richard is haunted by what she is keeping from him, and she is wrestling with her complicated relationships with her parents. A camping trip with Mara’s soon-to-be stepson offers Jen an opportunity for grace and wonder to reframe the past and the future.
Readers learn about Claire through Mara and Jen’s memories. She was beautiful and idealistic, but in a dangerous relationship. She echoes throughout the novel, bringing characters together in compelling ways. For Mara and Jen, Claire’s death opens the floodgate of the rushing waters they were barely containing behind a dam to begin with. They almost drown in those waters the first year without her.
Mara and Jen are a pair now, whereas with Claire they were a trio. The change, and the violence that wrought it, transformed them. Millet’s exploration of this transformation is astute, perceptive and sharply rendered. FAIR ONES is a dialogue-driven novel, but there is a lot of action that takes place and so much emotional depth and development as well. Millet is masterful in handling it all.
It is overly simplistic to say that this is a book about loss or death. And it is pat to say that this is a book about life, but that is probably more accurate. Mara and Jen are growing older, navigating aging, and dealing with the disappointments they feel in the generation before them and the hopes they have for the generation after them. They are in love but nervous about it. They are deeply connected and very sad, and they have actual visions that are more powerful than dreams.
FAIR ONES is tragic, sometimes funny, weird, bitterly realistic and super smart. As always, Lydia Millet’s work is highly recommended.
Reviewed by Sarah Rachel Egelman on October 16, 2026
Fair Ones: A Double Novel
- Publication Date: October 6, 2026
- Genres: Fiction, Women's Fiction
- Hardcover: 384 pages
- Publisher: W. W. Norton & Company
- ISBN-10: 1324123672
- ISBN-13: 9781324123675


